Seven months into Summer Lee’s first term representing Pennsylvania’s 12th District in the U.S. House of Representatives, her district’s voters should soberly reevaluate whether she deserves our continued support.
On Tuesday Congress passed a “sense of Congress” resolution stating that “Israel is not a racist or apartheid state; Congress rejects all forms of antisemitism and xenophobia; and the United States will always be a staunch partner and supporter of Israel.” The vote was 412-9-1. Rep. Lee was one of the “nine progressive Democrats of color,” according to NBC News, who voted against the resolution. (Her progressive colleague Chris Deluzio is recorded as “not voting.”)
On Wednesday, under the headline “Summer Lee votes ‘no’ on resolution backing Israel,” the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle noted that “the vote came as Israel’s President Issac Herzog was in Washington for meetings with president Joe Biden … [and] an address to both chambers of Congress.”
What the Chronicle did not point out is that this vote also coincided with the final phase in the Tree of Life mass murder trial. The deadliest attack on Jews in American history occurred in Squirrel Hill, known far beyond Pittsburgh as one of our country’s most vibrant communities. It is also part of Ms. Lee’s Congressional district.
I am not alone, though, in noting the unfortunate timing. Ms. Lee herself was bold enough to mention it in a statement explaining — or defending — her decision. Most of her Tuesday press release is a list of government funds she “requested” and “has secured” for renovating the synagogue.
But it is her opening remarks that are actually relevant to her vote. Claiming the “MAGA resolution treat[s] antisemitism as a political football,” Ms. Lee stated, “I condemn antisemitism and xenophobia in all its forms. Whether we’re talking about India, Israel, or Sri Lanka, we are not true allies if we cannot push our partners to uphold basic human rights and democratic values. I cannot vote for unconditional support of any nation-state.”
Read More
Setting her ad hominem reasoning aside for the moment, let’s take another look at the resolution’s exact words. Rep. Lee quoted its second statement accurately — like Congress, she rejects “all forms” of “antisemitism and xenophobia” — but she misrepresented its final line. She turned “staunch partner and supporter of Israel” into “unconditional support.”
“Staunch” and “unconditional” are not synonyms. In fact, staunch allies have the firmest standing from which to confront and hold one another accountable. Ugly distortions and demands from perpetually hostile people are generally dismissed, unless made at gunpoint.
It is true that the Congressional resolution was drafted by a Trump-supporting Texan, Rep. August Pfluger. It is also true that the resolution came in response to remarks from one of Rep. Lee’s allies, Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus. She ignited a political firestorm Saturday at a progressive forum when she said, “We have been fighting to make it clear that Israel is a racist state.”
Jewish Democrats immediately denounced Ms. Jayapal’s remarks, and 195 Democratic representatives voted in favor of what Ms. Lee sneers at as a “MAGA resolution.” (Ms. Jayapal voted for the resolution.)
Is it actually Rep. Pfluger or Rep. Jayapal who is using antisemitism as a “political football”? If Summer Lee can’t agree with anything put forward by a MAGA Republican, is she okay aligning herself with Ms. Jayapal’s words (though not her vote)?
No political action is free of politics. The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle suggested Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy supported the resolution as “an opportunity to divide Democrats.”
Even as they voted yes, some Democrats “lambasted Republicans for standing by their decision to have Robert F. Kennedy Jr. testify Thursday before the House weaponization subcommittee,” NBC News reported, “after he was reported to have made some racist, antisemitic and factually incorrect comments."
Both parties have plenty of house-cleaning to do, yet most members joined together to support a nation under constant existential threat.
Those opposed were, news outlets noted, uniformly “people of color,” but they include Black Americans, an Indian immigrant, a Palestinian-American, a Somali immigrant and a Guatemalan-American. We all tend to see and hear through the prism of our own pain, but interpreting the longstanding Middle East conflict as primarily a matter of “race” is a serious error.
Most Jews are Zionist, though the number might not be the 95% so often claimed, and Israel is their homeland. The diaspora, Zionism, the 1949 Armistice, the Six-Day War, the two-state solution — many, many books have been written about this very complicated saga in human history; a newspaper column can’t add much.
What is certain, however, is that when other people’s identity has been assaulted and the trauma is fresh, we speak and act with wisdom and respect. This should be especially true of the person elected to represent those in pain.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Mayor Ed Gainey isn’t talking, but he is taking.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.