I’ve heard it more times than I can count, from both Republicans and Democrats around town: “There’s no way Summer Lee can hold onto this district” — that is, the 12th congressional district, including Pittsburgh, south and east suburbs, and western Westmoreland County.
Evidence for this assumption always includes exhibits like these tweets, from May 3: “As a young, progressive Black woman in office, I’m asked all the time whether I can ‘get along’ w/ my racist, fascist colleagues who don’t believe I deserve equal rights, and insist it’s our job to promote bipartisanship w/those who explicitly only seek to hinder us. // I never hear y’all ask my racist, fascist colleagues if they can stop harming marginalized colleagues long enough to ‘get along’ w/us + imply they should lose jobs for their inability to do so the way they imply we can’t rep our communities if we can’t be friends w/them. Wonder why.”
This is a rather different way of representing Pittsburgh in Congress than we are accustomed to. Former U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, in contrast, famously lived for a time in a D.C. house with conservative Republicans, some of whom would have been caught up in Ms. Lee’s rhetorical dragnet.
But the GOP isn’t the real target of Ms. Lee’s tweets: That would be the moderate, establishment Democrats who have opposed her at every turn, and whom she aggravates even more than she aggravates Republicans. They are the “y’all” — the people who counsel her to be tame and affable and bipartisan; the people who, she implies, are practically in league with the racists and fascists because they see her, and people like her, as the primary problem to be corrected.
This kind of devil-may-care bombast is not the way politics is supposed to work — around here, at least. And yet here we are, and there she is. And the more I think about it, the more I think she can last.
Kayfabe politics
Read More
The congresswoman from Swissvale posted these remarks in response to a video of Florida lawmakers, Democrats and Republicans, doing a line dance on the floor of the capitol in Tallahassee. After Gov. Ron DeSantis had pushed through an unprecedented package of conservative culture-war legislation, this looked to many on the left like Stockholm Syndrome at best, and cruel capitulation at worst.
And who could disagree? If Florida Democrats really believed that Mr. DeSantis and his legislative supermajority were blazing a path to authoritarianism, then they would not be doing the Cha-Cha Slide, or whatever it was, with the fascist vanguard. But, a reasonable person should infer, despite their words they do not actually believe that, and so they turned the House floor into a dance floor.
The Florida incident is an unusually ridiculous example of an everyday phenomenon: politicians using incendiary rhetoric about bigotry or socialism or various phobias, then acting perfectly chummy with the people they’ve just condemned as enemies of the human race. There’s a word for this kind of staged conflict, from the lingo of professional wrestling: kayfabe, said to be pig Latin for “be fake.”
The problem with kayfabe politics is that, in order to keep the audience entertained, the staged rhetorical battles have to become increasingly extreme, which extends the distance between harsh words and collegial actions. People will tolerate a certain amount of fakeness in politics — but only so much.
Breaking the illusion
The appeal of Summer Lee, therefore, isn’t just the substance of her left-wing views, which are shared a small minority of the voters in her district. (Though that’s all you need to win a low-turnout primary — a lesson county executive hopefuls Michael Lamb and John Weinstein have astoundingly failed to learn, as they watch Sara Innamorato zoom past them.) What draws people to Ms. Lee, enough to win every election she’s ever contested, is that her observable actions match her stated beliefs.
She breaks the kayfabe illusion. With Summer Lee, everything is real.
She doesn’t say her conservative colleagues are racist fascists just to rile up her base before going bowling with them; as far as we can tell, she treats them like racist fascists — no negotiation, no compromise, no quarter.
Does this mean she also believes a solid proportion of her constituents are racist fascists? Yes, of course. She does not like them, and does not pretend to like them, because she thinks they are wrong and malicious. She thinks power must be used to crush them, because (in her reckoning) they believe power must be used to crush her, and people like her. That is politics: crush, or be crushed.
Not everyone who votes for Summer Lee thinks of politics this starkly, but when the alternative is such transparent fakery, the real has a certain appeal — even if it comes with a frisson of danger. At least it feels like the actual power of the people is being brought to bear, and not just the People’s Elbow.
Swept away
With a little more than a week before this year’s municipal primary, greenhorn progressive legislator Sara Innamorato — not as personally brash but just as politically disruptive as Ms. Lee — appears poised to sweep away another withered crop of white men. You could see it coming for months, but no one did anything to stop it.
That’s because the local Democratic establishment, or what’s left of it, can’t combat what it doesn’t understand: a left-wing movement full of youthful energy and brash authenticity that wins precisely because it breaks the rules of respectable politics.
The conventional wisdom about the importance of civility and moderation, it turns out, was just as illusory as the staged conflicts themselves: It only works if enough people buy into it. And once the spell is broken, it’s almost impossible to recast.
Summer Lee and her acolytes are winning the game by showing that the rules were fake. And as long as their establishment antagonists insist on playing by those rules, the left will just keep winning.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.