Catching up on three days’ newspapers all in one sitting, I lost track of the recent past’s exact chronology. Which day was the announcement of a new South Hills department store? Thursday.
The alarming prediction on Greenland’s melting ice sheet? Tuesday.
The multi-day mental mash-up has sparked ideas and connections that wouldn’t have happened if spread out (and forgotten) through the week.
I consider the mash-up serendipitous, but you might not agree, especially if you’re a millennial or younger. I’ll try to keep these musings from becoming too grumpy-boomer-ish — partly so I won’t feel like, well, a grumpy boomer, but also because I really want you to think it over too.
Consider the news that an Iowa-based, family-run department store chain, Von Maur, is taking over the old Sears space at South Hills Village. The PG article’s intro rightly observed, “Amazon has gobbled up much of the retail market. Malls across the country are shuttering in record numbers.”
I saw this within moments of reading Thursday’s front-page article stating that “human-caused climate change has set in motion massive ice losses in Greenland,” losses which scientists think are irreversible.
Climate change has many contributing factors, but one we can address more easily than others is our voracious level of consumption. As the biggest e-commerce corporation in existence, one that has wiped out thousands, perhaps millions, of jobs and smaller businesses, Amazon handily represents our addiction to consumption and instant gratification. Its delivery trucks race through our streets seven days a week.
According to Amazon’s own analytics, two out of three American adults have an Amazon Prime membership — myself included. Further, “85% of consumers aged 18 to 32 buy online at least a few times per week.” But isn’t this the same demographic that is most alarmed by climate change?
What about the mind-blowing amount of energy required to ferry to your front door any item you desire from anywhere on the globe? And yet more energy to support the global online network that makes the whole process run?
The alert reader may counter my anti-e-commerce argument by pointing out that bricks-and-mortar shops and shoppers have to burn fossil fuels too. Yes, but boxes with more than one item are shipped.
Apparel is Amazon’s second-biggest sales category, and returns can reach as high as 40% (versus 5 to 10% for in-store shopping). That’s an incredible amount of waste — all for the convenience of trying stuff on at home. Is any time actually saved?
It seems, on balance, that the slower way — with more personal interaction and less stuff — is a more humane, less angsty way to live.
Many good things cannot be quantified. And some things are important enough to ignore the fear-mongering, including mine.
Right below the report about Greenland’s melting ice was an article on pianist Hélène Grimaud visiting the Steinway factory in Hamburg, Germany. She stopped while on tour with the Pittsburgh Symphony to select a new grand piano that will be shipped from city to city for her concerts.
Ms. Grimaud lives part-time in rural New York — the Steinway Company’s home state — but apparently prefers the sound of the instruments produced in Germany. And the German factory prefers to get the pianos’ critical cast-iron plates shipped in from Springfield, Ohio.
Most of us will never need — nor be able to afford — a Steinway, but it’s important to preserve and even celebrate a world in which excellence trumps practicality.
The same principle applies at humbler price points. The Von Maur stores feature all-day live piano music. Steinway or not, that’s not cheap.
You younger adults who nab cool clothes at consignment shops in your walkable neighborhood, repurpose vintage furniture instead of buying disposable particle-board stuff and fix up Pittsburgh’s ample stock of old houses — you’re my heroes. You prove that excellence and conscientious living can co-exist.
You remind me of the creatives on my favorite new fixer-upper show, “In With the Old.” I just devoured every episode via, of course, my Amazon Prime subscription. Electricity used — totally worth it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.