Some city officials apparently want you to enjoy Pittsburgh without using your eyes or nose. Some of them think you shouldn’t mind eating lunch in a public toilet.

Not all of them, though. Mayor Ed Gainey definitely gets it. He understands that making our Downtown safe and attractive is essential to its financial viability. In fact, he announced it as a priority last November, just a few weeks after the election: “Downtown is not as clean or as healthy as it should be.”

He shared this with major city stakeholders in a meeting mere moments after he and former State Rep. Jake Wheatley (now his chief of staff) encountered feces on Smithfield Street during a walking tour of the city.

Which means, eight months later, he needs to have a heart-to-heart with the people responsible for carrying out his administration’s policies.

Advertise with us

The Planning Commission, in particular, is not singing from the Gainey hymnal — not if they think it’s okay to make Point Park University battle the nasty sights and odors left by overnight visitors to its public square at 350 Forbes Avenue.

But, after last Tuesday’s hearing, that seems to be how the commission is leaning.

The commission required the open public space before green-lighting plans for the new Pittsburgh Playhouse a few years ago. It actually lies a little below street-level, accessed by stairs or a long, comfortable ramp.

A second floor balcony overlooking Forbes and reached by an always-open staircase has tables and chairs for daytime meals — or nighttime … whatever.

Now the university wants to install fencing and gates to prevent access between 9 p.m. and 8 a.m., claiming that all kinds of illegal activity occurs on its property overnight.

Advertise with us

The Playhouse celebrated its “topping off” — installation of the final steel beam — on Nov. 30, 2017, four years to the day before Mayor Gainey’s foul-smelling tour of the Fifth and Forbes corridor.

Last Tuesday commission members expressed concerns that the mere sight of fencing along the Forbes Avenue courtyard would discourage daytime use. (As if unpleasant odors weren’t already a major turn-off.)

The commission wants “a place that is inviting to the public during those normal business hours.” Inviting to whom? Put bluntly: Fencing isn’t the problem. Poop is.

The courtyard’s illicit overnight uses are diametrically opposed to legitimate daytime uses. Because bad smells linger.

The city can’t have it both ways. In attempting to, they’re forcing unreasonable costs on property owners.

Advertise with us

They are not doing so consistently, either. At 10 p.m. Wednesday night, hours after reading Post-Gazette reporter Mark Belko’s thorough coverage of the Planning Commission meeting, I made the short Deutschtown-to-Downtown drive, to take a fresh look at the Playhouse courtyard.

En route I passed the EQT Plaza in the heart of the Cultural District. Patrons were streaming from the Benedum Center, where “A Chorus Line” had just ended, but if they’d tried to access the Seventh Street walkway to EQT’s large, lovely terrace, they’d have found the gate chained and a “Plaza Closed” sign.

The much larger entrance on Liberty Avenue was likewise shut with a massive, padlocked fence. Sidewalk cafes nearby were crowded, but the unstaffed “public space” outside EQT was verboten. And reasonably so.

“The city can’t clean up Downtown by itself,” Mr. Gainey told stakeholders back in November. “We’re going to need you. Our Downtown … should be the safest place in America. And we can make it that way if we work together.”

Well, isn’t Point Park trying to do exactly that? To strike a balance between public access and public safety?

Advertise with us

Apart from Playhouse patrons mingling at intermission, there is “no need,” as their spokesman said Tuesday, “for the public to access the area” at night.

Point Park is an excellent Pittsburgh partner, an elegant campus in the shadow of PPG Place’s glittering chic. The city should accommodate the university — and every other stakeholder struggling with the unpleasant consequences of tragic addiction and mental health issues.

Just as the city’s resources have limits, so do the budgets — and goodwill — of its private-sector partners.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com