When Point Park University debuted its new Pittsburgh Playhouse Downtown in 2018, it came with the requirement that an outdoor courtyard and second floor terrace would be open to the public.
But with some now treating the spaces as a “Downtown urinal,” the university is seeking to fence the area in and close off access overnight — a proposal that doesn’t sit well with city planners.
It was one of two Downtown projects to go before the Planning Commission on Tuesday for briefings. The other involves the effort by PNC Financial Services Group to rehab and reuse the historic Skinny Building and John M. Roberts & Co. buildings on Wood Street.
Point Park’s proposal entails blocking off what are now three open archways at the playhouse on Forbes Avenue by installing either 5½-foot or 6½-foot fences and two gates.
The street-level archways lead to the outdoor courtyard and provide access to the second-floor outdoor terrace. The Planning Commission required the open spaces in approving the playhouse project in 2015.
Under the proposal, the public would have access to the courtyard and terrace from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. After that, the spaces would be closed off to the public unless someone is attending an event or is a guest of the university.
Read More
In making the case for the changes, Shawn Gallagher, Point Park’s attorney, told the commission that the spaces have become “a haven for criminal activity” after hours.
“If you walk by, it’s like a Downtown urinal,” he said. “It’s been very problematic keeping it clean and getting rid of the smell. If you walk by, it’s kind of overwhelming.”
Point Park’s preference, he noted, would be to install a 6½-foot fence, saying that is more aesthetically pleasing than the 5½-foot option and provides better security.
The university also plans to install three signs stating that the spaces will be open to the public from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m.
After the briefing, the university released a statement: “Constructing a fence to the outdoor courtyard would allow us to appropriately secure the property overnight when there would be no need for the public to access the area. Should we get the approval, the courtyard would remain otherwise open to the public.”
Nonetheless, Kate Rakus of the city Planning Department told the commission that the planning staff was uneasy with the proposed changes.
“Staff had concerns about the height of the proposed fencing and the gates and they felt they created an inhospitable space for pedestrians and would thus discourage the use of the urban open space,” she said.
“We understand the security concerns, but we want to make sure that when people are walking by ... it looks like a place that is inviting to the public during those normal business hours.”
While Mr. Gallagher said the spaces should look more welcoming and accessible with the gates open, commission member Rachel O’Neill took issue with that assessment.
“It seems like it would be a little questionable how inviting it would be when it is open during the day,” she said.
Ms. O’Neill asked for more detail about how the fence would look and the materials involved.
“It’s a tough spot. I understand the security issue and you want it to be a space that’s maintained and open to the public during the day. But to the extent that it could be more inviting, were there any other options explored for this, any other design?”
Mr. Gallagher replied that the proposed fencing for the archways matches the existing railing in place on the second floor terrace overlooking Forbes.
Also Tuesday, PNC mapped out its plans for the Skinny and Roberts buildings at the corner of Wood and Forbes less than a block from the playhouse.
The bank acquired both buildings from the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority for $1.3 million. It also acquired another at 433 Wood next to them from a private owner for $1.35 million.
PNC intends to demolish the three-story structure at 433 Wood and replace it with a five-story one that will house the elevators, restrooms and stairways for the three-building complex.
At the Skinny Building, considered by its enthusiasts to be the world’s thinnest structure measuring a mere 5 feet, 2 inches wide and 80 feet long, PNC is planning some type of restaurant or food and beverage operation at street level in keeping with its history.
The upper floors would be devoted to the display of digital or physical art in keeping with its agreement with the URA.
PNC is planning to restore and update the facades of both the Skinny and Roberts buildings and to renovate the interiors so that all three buildings are connected.
It ultimately plans to use the complex for flexible office or assembly space or a combination of the two.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.