During the 2020 presidential campaign, a testy town hall exchange between an Iowa dad and candidate Elizabeth Warren over her plan to cancel student debt made headlines.
“My daughter is getting out of school. I’ve saved all my money [so] she doesn’t have any student loans,” the dad said. “Am I going to get my money back?”
“Of course not,” Sen. Warren replied.
“I saved my money. … I worked a double shift,” the man continued. “So you’re going to pay for people who didn’t save any money and those of us who did the right thing get screwed?”
Yes. As Joe Biden’s administration incrementally adopts Sen. Warren’s crusade, this family and many others are definitely being cheated.
Borrowing to acquire an asset (education) is not necessarily a bad thing to do, but changing the rules of the game after it’s been played definitely is.
Read More
You foolish people who worked, saved and carefully paid your way — you’re not going to get reimbursed, but you will get a share of the big borrowers’ bill.
The only question now is how big that bill will be. The answer is: as big as necessary for Joe Biden to hang onto young voters.
It is one thing to forgive the debts of those defrauded by deceitful for-profit colleges. It is another thing entirely to erase debts of those who borrowed carelessly and can afford to pay what they owe.
The debts don’t actually disappear, of course. They get transferred to the rest of us as taxpayers, added to the ever-mushrooming deficit. The nation’s debt, budget obligations and money supply all impact inflation. So we all pay now and we all pay later — whether we went to college or not.
It’s worth noting that 58% of Americans above age 25 do not hold college degrees. Since, as a rule, in most industries, individuals’ incomes rise with their level of education, forcing the less-educated to assume the debts of the more-educated is patently unfair.
No matter. Political solutions to some borrowers’ struggles are proceeding on several different tracks: forgiving some types of student loans (as the Department of Education did in June), extending the repayment pause for a few more months and considering whether to erase a portion of most borrowers’ debts.
That last possibility is in play right now. CNBC reported in early June that the White House was “zeroing in on cancelling $10,000 for all borrowers who earn less than $150,000 per year.” On July 6, Inside Higher Ed reported that this move is “expected” soon.
Here are a few more important numbers to ponder: Per the 2020 census, the nation’s median household income is $67,521. Why would an individual with an income of $150,000 — more than double America’s median household income — be the cut-off point for loan cancellation?
Moreover, of the 44.7 million Americans with college debt, 16 million owe $10,000 or less, so their entire debt would be erased.
Why would this windfall take place without means-testing? Why would a person earning up to $150,000 annually get his debt erased at the expense of non-college-educated taxpayers earning (as most do) less than half his salary?
When that Iowa dad ended his unsatisfactory interchange with Elizabeth Warren, he summarized the situation thus: “You’re laughing at me.”
Ms. Warren thanked him for his time. Offered a do-over by CBS News a few days later, she opened with word salad: “We build a future going forward by making it better.”
Sure, okay. But exactly whose future will massive debt forgiveness make better?
“By that same logic,” she continued, “what would we have done? Not started Social Security because we didn’t start it last week for you?”
Her “logic” is deeply flawed. As a nation we provide a social safety net for life’s basic necessities. A college education is not one of them.
This unfair policy, now being pushed by Joe Biden’s White House, hurts more of us than it helps. It mocks the country’s financially prudent and its less educated. Perhaps the last laugh will be at the ballot box.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.