“First do no harm” is not actually in the Hippocratic Oath, but it aptly captures a basic principle of medicine. Some scholars see its origin in a work attributed to Hippocrates and titled — fittingly, for these times — “Of the Epidemics.”
But in these times, the political authorities who craft medical policies that affect millions of people should alter the historic phrase: “Do the least amount of harm possible.”
Nowhere is that approach more urgent than in our schools.
Over the past two years it has often seemed that no matter what we did to address the ravages of the pandemic, there was a significant downside. Abrupt lockdowns closed some businesses forever. Suspension of “elective” treatments caused irreparable harm to people with urgent needs. Recovering addicts without support group meetings overdosed.
Those for whom the harm will linger for longest are our children. As we knew well over a year ago, though, children face the lowest COVID-19 health risks of any age group by far. For them the draconian policies have long been ridiculous.
Only now, however, are governors across the nation dropping school mask mandates. Tuesday’s Boston Globe called for the governor of Massachusetts to lift the mask mandate for students and staff, noting that New Jersey and Connecticut had just done so, and that Pennsylvania had way back in January.
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf’s announcement was as cautious as you’d expect: It is “time to prepare for a transition back to a more normal setting.” (That’s one qualification away from farce: “We must begin to consider to start to think about the possibility of maybe transitioning …”)
Suspending the mandate, however welcome a decision, does not set policy for individual school districts. Indeed, as soon as the North Allegheny and Upper St. Clair school boards voted to end masking mandates, they were sued by small groups of students and their parents, who assert that mask-optional policies could expose them to COVID-19 and therefore violate the Americans with Disabilities Act.
While we must be vigilant on behalf of society’s most vulnerable, we also must acknowledge that all children are vulnerable to a variety of mask-related ills.
Maybe we could “follow the science.”
After a year of wearing ineffective cloth masks, we now have ready access to good masks. According to the Food & Drug Administration, the N95 respirator achieves “very efficient filtration of airborne particles.”
The disposable surgical masks that are handed out everywhere “help block large-particle droplets, splashes, sprays, or splatter, … keeping it from reaching your mouth and nose,” the FDA website says. “Surgical masks may also help reduce exposure of your saliva and respiratory secretions to others.”
What both descriptions make clear is that the mask’s primary function is to protect the wearer. Therefore medically vulnerable people should wear good masks.
Although the FDA noted in September 2021 that the N95 is “not designed for children,” other entities (such as The New York Times) have commissioned lab tests of many new masks to find those effective “for kids and toddlers.”
Toddlers? A study at the University of Wisconsin-Madison found that when elementary school-age kids were asked to assign one of six emotions to facial images, they were correct about unmasked faces 66 percent of the time. When the faces were masked, the children’s scores dropped drastically, all the way to 18 percent for correctly recognizing fear.
While UWM researchers put a positive spin on this result (“a rate better than chance”!), I would not feel reassured if my kids were that young and that clueless about basic human interaction. I’d be alarmed. If my child who needed speech therapy were 13 instead of 32 and trying to make progress without being able to see the teacher’s mouth, I’d be incensed.
Scientists will continue to analyze and argue over how masks impact emotional and linguistic development, but parents know their own children’s vulnerabilities.
Some kids need masks. Many more will benefit from a return to social normalcy. All of us should want policies that do as little harm as possible to all the children we love.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.