Witness the power of one person following his conscience: If Alejandro Villanueva had not put Alwyn Cashe’s name on his helmet in September, how many of us in Pittsburgh would ever have heard his story?
And how much longer would justice have had to wait?
We might have caught news of Army Sgt. 1st Class Cashe’s heroism on Veterans Day — 15 years, almost to the day, after he died from terrible wounds sustained in Iraq. On Tuesday night, the Senate unanimously passed legislation making it possible for the president to award him the Medal of Honor, and several newspapers and television shows covered this yearslong effort beautifully on Wednesday.
Or maybe we’d have heard about it next week or next month, whenever an appropriate White House ceremony can be arranged with Sgt. Cashe’s family present. (It was news in military forums this summer when his son Andrew Cashe reached the halfway point in basic training at Fort Benning.)
As a former Army Ranger who won the Bronze Star for valor, Mr. Villanueva would naturally grieve the lack of recognition for Sgt. Cashe’s almost incomprehensible sacrifice: repeatedly entering a burning vehicle to rescue seven people while his own fuel-doused uniform was on fire. He died of his wounds three weeks later, on Nov. 8, 2005.
Once the president signs the legislation, Sgt. Cashe will become the first African American awarded the Medal of Honor for actions in Iraq or Afghanistan.
As you might recall, a lone Steeler’s decision to champion this posthumous recognition caused some real blowback. Was it worth it?
The story is inseparable from racial politics but transcends them. And its transcendence is what makes the story so important.
Prior to their Sept. 14 game against the New York Giants, the Steelers decided to put on their helmets the name of Antwon Rose II, the 17-year-old shot to death by East Pittsburgh police Officer Michael Rosfeld in 2018. Tried for criminal homicide in 2019, Mr. Rosfeld was acquitted by a jury brought in from Harrisburg due to weeks of local protests.
Mr. Villanueva decided to sidestep this complex tragedy to honor Sgt. Cashe instead. His decision upset teammates, offended Antwon Rose’s mother and made national news for weeks.
Two days after the Steelers-Giants game, Rep. Stephanie Murphy, whose district includes Sgt. Cashe’s hometown of Oviedo, Fla., introduced a House bill waiving the requirement that the Medal of Honor be awarded within five years of the relevant military action.
Did Mr. Villanueva’s bold gesture precipitate Rep. Murphy’s? The effort to recognize Sgt. Cashe’s sacrifice has certainly been underway for years, involves many people and began in the Army.
Then-Lt. Col Gary Brito immediately applied for Sgt. Cashe’s Silver Star but had limited information, since all survivors had been evacuated for critical medical treatment. As more became known, Lt. Col. Brito, who is also Black, began seeking the upgrade. He is now a three-star general and the Army’s deputy chief of staff for personnel.
In August, then-Secretary of Defense Mark T. Esper wrote a letter to Congress in support of the legislation, which, introduced in September, had bipartisan sponsorship in both chambers. Clearly momentum was building when Sgt. Cashe’s name appeared on Mr. Villanueva’s helmet, but the weeks of stories he garnered on news broadcasts, cable channels and sports shows also helped.
Sgt. Cashe’s sister, Kasinal Cashe White, recently told reporters that she “won’t allow anybody to make it a race thing.
“He did what he did not because he was Black, but because he was a soldier and because he loved his men.”
Whether what the good men do is interred in their bones or lives after them depends significantly on what we choose to remember and celebrate. The years required to grind through Army bureaucracy speak of our resistance to conflict and to correcting mistakes.
But once we do, we can embrace a narrative that unifies and inspires us. This soldier’s courage and nobility are things we can agree on. Recognizing his heroism was worth fighting for.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.