By far my favorite bumper sticker of this campaign season didn’t cross my path until Election Day, in a grocery store parking lot. On a half-red, half-blue rectangle with a band of white stars, the white-lettered slogan read, “Any Functioning Adult — 2020.” I laughed and stopped to take a photo.
Before that one, the best political sign I can recall was almost two years ago, posted at a friend’s front door. It said, “Make America Think Again.”
A clever tweak of the Trump brand, it clearly implies America stopped thinking at some point, possibly in 2016.
But anyone who spends even five seconds reading anything on Twitter knows that lots of Americans prioritize reacting over thinking — from the White House and New York Times on down. (Or is that “on up”? Yes, “up.”) And Twitter has been around for almost 15 years.
(Founder Jack Dorsey told the Los Angeles Times that the name was chosen for its twin definitions: “a short burst of inconsequential information” and “chirps from birds.” Nailed it!)
The two slogans, “Make America Think Again” and “Any Functioning Adult — 2020,” capture a real quandary many voters experienced this year. So many of us wondered whether either major party presidential candidate is a fully functioning adult that we were actually thinking harder than ever about the consequences of our vote.
Should we overlook character flaws and serious ethical lapses in furtherance of our favored policies? (That query applies to both sides.)
Was the candidate’s tone (aggressive or mild) central to fulfilling his promises? Or detrimental to the American experiment? Those are serious considerations.
To be sure, there are plenty of examples of non-thinking, of conclusions based on misinformation and party propaganda, to go around. Democrats like to point out that lots of Republicans still believe President Barack Obama was born in Kenya. A 2014 YouGov poll showed 38% think it’s possible he was born there, while 28% (and 7% of Democrats!) are certain he is Kenyan by birth.
The same reputable organization, though, found in March 2018 that 66% of Democrats (and 18% of Republicans!) believe Russia “probably” or “definitely” tampered with 2016 vote tallies — with actual voting — to get Mr. Trump elected.
With the culture awash in such misinformation, critical thinking skills are more important than ever, but being a “functioning adult” entails more than clear thinking about the news, something much greater: empathy and moral imagination.
A February poll from the Pew Research Center displays a link between our anxiety over untrustworthy information (especially via social media) and our assessment that other citizens cannot be trusted to make good political decisions.
Mutual confidence was at 69% in 1997, while mistrust was at 35. Confidence eroded and mistrust grew until they crossed around 2009-2010. They peaked in 2016, but then, somewhat astonishingly, we began a course correction and had made significant progress toward one another by early 2018. The positive trend was short-lived, and it’s almost as bad as it ever was. Almost.
Last Monday, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette columnist Diana Nelson Jones wrote of two Mt. Lebanon families, next-door neighbors, whose yards sport opposing political signs — as well as signs pointing to each other’s houses that say “We [Heart] Them” and, inside the hearts, “One Nation.”
That’s how fully functioning adults live.
The Pew study refrains from policy recommendations but notes that as we set aside politics, we report more trust and fellow feeling. You’ve probably seen this phenomenon unfold in your community or friendships or church. The bigger one’s political agenda, the more likely one is to see those who are not like-minded as adversaries rather than neighbors. The ensuing agitation wastes time and energy.
But when we insist on focusing on a common cause — whether it’s rebuilding a neighborhood or a nation — and on treating all as our equals, endowed with unalienable rights, our differences can be overcome. Democracy deserves this effort.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.