Page 1 of Wednesday’s Post-Gazette reported Pennsylvania’s largest-yet one-day spike in new COVID-19 cases.
On page 2, a headline read, “Virus pushes El Paso, Juarez to the brink.” Already-full hospitals face a surge in cases blamed on family gatherings and multi-generational homes.
Below this was news from Italy, where widespread protests, some violent, entered a fifth day as citizens denounced a new month-long closure of restaurants, theaters and gyms due to rising COVID rates.
Next to this article, the “Thought for Today,” serendipitously, was from Jean-Jacques Rousseau: “I prefer liberty with danger to peace with slavery.”
This quote usually resounds when we are grappling with overbearing government, which is historically appropriate. Rousseau was quoting a Polish duke to insist on separation of executive and legislative functions.
Thomas Jefferson borrowed it. Ben Franklin coined his own version — “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety” — as he warned against ceding the right to tax the mighty Penn family’s real estate in exchange for their one-time donation. The taxes were for military defense during the French and Indian War.
The threat we now face has a modern twist. Does the greater danger exist in tiny toxic droplets hovering in the very air we breathe, or in over-protective, even alarmist measures that are crippling economies worldwide right now and ensure years of suffering to come?
From the news stories cited above, and from our own day-to-day experience, it’s obvious we don’t agree on answers to that question. What is also clear is that a growing number of ordinary citizens are chafing at seven months of anti-coronavirus measures.
This frustration, though, does not seem to be shared by our leaders, here or elsewhere, and why would it be? The higher up the government ladder we look, the more we see the privileges of wealth. Though wealth does not buy immunity to COVID-19, it does buy distance. So do the perks of high government office.
Those making high-handed decisions likely to hurt working-class families for years ahead are insulated from the impact of those decisions. And since they’ll be out of office by the time the consequences of their decisions emerge, they will escape accountability.
But we are the government — restaurant owners, salon stylists, college students, you and I. We expect those elected by us, from among us, to protect us — to a reasonable degree — without destroying our futures.
Most precautions, apart from hand-washing and masks, carry a downside. There has to be a commonsense balance between “liberty with danger” and “peace with slavery” — whether the “slavery” is overbearing government now or economic devastation to come.
A friend who teaches middle school in a Southern state reports that his district has a mix of in-person and virtual instruction. Teachers with vulnerable health were given first choice for virtual teaching spots, he says. In-person classes are going well, but the kids learning online “are failing tremendously.”
So is this a reasonable balance of current safety with future well-being? We should demand assessments in education and business and adjust our precautions accordingly. We should be able to agree on rolling measures that let us respond with calm, not panic, to changing circumstances. But many places are missing the mark.
On Wednesday, the same day as the PG stories cited above, the Chicago Tribune editorialized against an executive order from Gov. Jay Pritzker (net worth, $3.4 billion) shutting all restaurants in Chicago and several counties. The piece pointed out his order’s excess, its misdirection and its devastation “to a backbone of Illinois’ economy.”
The same edition reported on two sisters — ages 18 and 21, with no criminal record — who bashed a store security guard with a trash can and stabbed him 27 times (none requiring surgery) for insisting they wear masks.
People are struggling, lashing out, losing their hope and their humanity. We the people have to insist on a better way. It’s on us.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.