If impeachment were not such a grave matter, you might actually find President Donald Trump’s telephone calls to the Ukrainian president good for a few giggles.
Each transcript carries a reminder that it is actually a memorandum — not a verbatim record but a compilation from those who listened in on the call. Despite the committee approach, the “tel-cons” magically capture the special flavor of Mr. Trump’s speech patterns.
Although he achieved great success in real estate years ago, Mr. Trump has never shed the style of the mid-level, wannabe kind of developer — the braggadocio and the insistent, numbing repetitiveness meant to wear down any opposition. Much of this obviously was edited out of “The Apprentice” episodes, but nobody edits live campaign speeches, alas.
For the faint of heart (like me), blustery developer-speak is easier to endure on the printed page, and our civic duty obliges us to read the Ukraine phone-call records. Impeachment turns upon whether Mr. Trump was leveraging American aid to enlist a foreign government’s help on a personal quest, rather than for a national objective.
Impeachment may rest, therefore, on the average citizen’s ability, or willingness, to read. If all of us assessed the memos and then answered the pollsters’ robo calls, our leaders in Congress would know which way to lead. This could save the nation weeks of anguish!
And how can we not read, when such a cornucopia of superlatives awaits?
Read More
“That was an incredible election,” “a fantastic election,” “we have a tremendous economy,” “you will be a fantastic president,” “the results are incredible — they’re very impressive for us.”
It’s like high-school sophomores doing their first Model U.N.
Apparently the style is spreading, too, because the last quote in the series above was from Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy. Perhaps he was trying to ingratiate himself.
Gaseous inexactitude creates problems. It lends itself to a wide variety of interpretations — enough that Speaker Nancy Pelosi thinks she should proceed with impeachment. Enough that Trump administration folks are still arguing about what their boss meant.
Enough, perhaps, that independent-minded citizens might shrug and say it could go either way — it depends on how you want to connect the dots.
In the July 25, 2019, phone call, Mr. Zelenskiy is the first to express his desire to “drain the swamp” in Ukraine, the first to mention Mr. Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani, the first to note that Ukraine wants to buy more weaponry from the U.S. — all of it in quick succession.
Mr. Trump slows down the conversation, backtracking to an earlier point each time Zelenskiy raises a new one. He does clearly ask for Ukraine to look at events in the 2016 election and to cooperate with the attorney general “to get to the bottom of it.”
And then the word salad really flies: he mentions the prosecutor that former Vice President Joe Biden bragged about getting fired and “a lot of talk about Biden’s son” but nothing specific, just the usual muddle.
Among other things, critics scoff at Mr. Trump’s mention of CrowdStrike, the company that investigated the 2016 hacking of Democratic National Committee emails and that still figures in right-wing conspiracy theories. But to the considerable extent that these critics are the same partisans who spent two years peddling the “Russian collusion” theory, they haven’t much credibility.
Careful readers have to ask whether Mr. Trump’s responses to Mr. Zelenskiy and the points he raises himself are reasonable or inappropriate, self-serving or patriotic. It’s usually a mix of all those when politicians speak, though some are more adept at hiding their self-interest than others.
Unfortunately (or will it be “fortunately”?) for Mr. Trump, the transcripts read like most people’s conversations most of the time — open to interpretation.
If the Democratic House votes to impeach but the Republican Senate does not follow, Mr. Trump will head into the 2020 election claiming vindication. The muddle will continue. Maybe that is each side’s end game — just keep stirring things up.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.