The old wisdom reaffirmed by the newest episode in our never-ending Washington circus is that we should pay special attention to the calmest voice in the room.
It’s often hard to tune out the shouters, of course. Between President Donald Trump, who manages to shout even on Twitter, and his adversaries, who decry the president’s every ill-advised word and deed in the loudest, harshest terms possible, it’s easy to overlook the quiet voices. You might well ask: Does Washington even have any of those anymore?
Yes, at least one: Michael Horowitz. The inspector general of the Department of Justice released his report last week on “Crossfire Hurricane,” the FBI investigation of Russian collusion in the 2016 election. The report’s release was nearly silent, easy to miss amid the impeachment chaos.
On Wednesday came part two. Mr. Horowitz testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee, at great length. The facts he put forward — the things he said and the things that he pointed out he could not say — all this calm analysis should have done much to deflate the hot-air talking heads blustering away on cable news.
But will too many of us miss the quiet heft of his work? I’d barely started the 434-page report before Mr. Horowitz’s Wednesday testimony, so I was relieved (like most senators, surely) when he joked about it being “hard to get through” and recommended the “pithy” 19-page summary.
In turn, the pithy summary of Mr. Horowitz’s hours of testimony is this: The calm man is disappointed. Disappointed and perplexed.
Read More
He delivered the bad news early and often, with help later on from senators’ questions. His findings hurt conspiracy theorists on both sides of the aisle, but the worst blow was delivered to the FBI. Its personnel are responsible for “serious significant failures,” errors, omissions and misleading statements at critical stages of “Crossfire Hurricane.”
And the calm man can’t explain why.
“The answers we got were not satisfactory,” Mr. Horowitz said, “We’re left trying to understand how could all these errors have occurred over a nine-month period or so among three teams, hand-picked, one of the highest-profile, if not the most high-profile, case of the FBI going to the very top of the organization and involving a presidential campaign.”
On Monday, immediately after the report’s release, former FBI director James Comey claimed vindication in a Washington Post essay. At the hearing Wednesday, Mr. Horowitz provided a quiet pushback. The report “doesn’t vindicate anybody at the FBI who touched this,” he said, “including the leadership.”
Republican senators pushed too, asking him repeatedly whether bias could have prompted the FBI’s actions. He maintained a judicious equilibrium.
“Whether it was sheer gross incompetence that led to this versus intentional misconduct or anything in between, and what the motivations are, I can’t tell you as I sit here today,” Mr. Horowitz said. “I don’t have enough evidence to reach a conclusion.”
Idaho Sen. Mike Crapo asked, “If someone were to characterize what you’re telling us to be that you’re telling us there’s ‘no bias’ here, that’s not what you’re telling us?”
Mr. Horowitz sorted through that question and responded, “That is not, as to the operation of these FISA [warrants], what I’m telling you.”
Mr. Crapo expressed doubt that so many errors “could be just accidental,” and Mr. Horowitz carefully agreed. “I would be skeptical. …There is such a range of conduct here that is inexplicable.”
The calm man delivered his analysis and leaves the rest of us to connect whichever dots strike us as salient. His job is to be the watchdog of the FBI. Changes have been made. Changes will be made.
Of course, a separate DOJ investigation into the origins of Crossfire Hurricane is ongoing, and in October, it quietly morphed into a criminal investigation. So Mr. Horowitz’s contribution to America’s political drama may turn out to have been the calm before the storm.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.