The headlines from Bernie Sanders’s post-heart attack interview nearly made it sound like he’d called rival Elizabeth Warren a dirty word: “Capitalist.”
To be sure, the Vermont senator and Democratic presidential candidate offered up this epithet only after fielding a battery of questions (from ABC News correspondent Jonathan Karl) on his health, medical records and campaign pace — a grilling topped off with the not-so-veiled hint that, because his and Ms. Warren’s policy positions are “pretty close to identical,” he should drop out.
And to be fair, Ms. Warren had called herself a “capitalist” first. She used it — “I am a capitalist to my bones” — in 2018 while speaking to a New England business organization. Perhaps she sensed she was addressing a skeptical audience.
Mr. Sanders also knows his audience — potential voters in the Democratic primary — so highlighting an alleged distinction from his rival was something he clearly considered a smart move.
His use of “capitalist” as a put-down raises two questions (at the very least): Is Ms. Warren, in fact, the dreaded C-word? And why do Democrats’ core voters think capitalism is something to be deplored?
What Ms. Warren’s national health policy is and just how high taxes will have to be to pay for it are unknowns, but the first question can still have a quick answer: If her policies are nearly identical to those of the U.S. Senate’s only avowed socialist, then no, she is not really a capitalist.
Read More
But why is capitalist, to some, a dirty word?
When I typed “what is a capitalist?” into an online search engine, the first definition to pop up was: “A wealthy person who uses money to invest in trade and industry for profit.” But that is not correct, in one very significant way.
Most capitalists in America are not wealthy. They are the millions and millions of people who risk whatever assets they have — nest eggs, sweat equity, brilliant ideas and countless hours of work — to create and build their own businesses.
It’s always fascinating to watch the politics of young entrepreneurs morph as they launch their dream businesses and run into the buzz saw of taxation and over-regulation. Our idealism eventually has to accommodate the realities of human nature, of risk and reward.
Some of these dreamers find eye-popping success. What’s heartening about the Forbes 400 List is how many of the nation’s richest people are self-made: Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, Larry Ellison, Mark Zuckerberg, etc.
Not only are they self-made, but many got rich selling their ideas and products to the very people (i.e. Gen-X, -Y and -Z’s tech-hungry kids) who supposedly deplore capitalism.
Bill Gates (Microsoft), Phil Knight (Nike) and Oprah Winfrey (queen of all media) did not steal their fortunes from the rest of us. Moreover, many titans of commerce are known for their very generous philanthropy. Do Mr. Sanders and Ms. Warren (both millionaires) believe they could do a better job redistributing the billionaires’ wealth than the billionaires already do?
In his ABC interview, Mr. Sanders said, “I will not tolerate for one second the greed and corruption, the income and wealth inequality, and so much suffering that is going on in this country today.”
He deplores greed, corruption and price-fixing. Good. I’d add to that list of woes the near-monopoly on ad revenue enjoyed by Google and Facebook, which has done so much to gut journalism. Some problems can be mitigated through better, fairer laws, but some are character flaws that no law will ever fix, nor will the “political revolution” he wants.
We are a nation of strivers and capitalists. We should applaud Mr. Sanders’s honesty. In calling for revolutionary change to America’s historically (and currently roaring) pro-risk, pro-reward economy, he has illuminated what a bad choice for president he would be.
And if Ms. Warren’s ideas are “pretty close to identical,” ditto for her.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.