Elizabeth Warren is climbing in the polls. Trump supporters must be pretty happy about that.
Say what you will about President Donald Trump — and it’s hard to imagine anything that has not been said — he is exactly as advertised. His voters knew what they were getting in 2016, and he hasn’t really grown in office.
Ms. Warren is just about everything Mr. Trump is not — female, academic, left-wing and articulate, for starters — but there’s one crucial quality that gives him the edge: authenticity.
Though Ms. Warren may be on track to win the Democratic nomination, the ways in which she’s been inauthentic — that is, dishonest about who she really is — could hurt her with pivotal voting groups in the general election: working-class whites, racial minorities and even women.
Mr. Trump won the 2016 contest in large part by appealing to working-class voters who mistrust the nation’s self-dealing, power-grabbing elites. They thought the chip on his shoulder aligned nicely with their resentment of insiders who game the system.
And, no matter whether she rose from “the ragged edge of the middle class,” Ms. Warren has gamed the system. She tells two origin myths that could, and should, trouble the very voters she must win.
Read More
The first is, of course, her now-debunked claim to be part Native American — a claim she made on her Texas bar license, all along her way to the Harvard Law School faculty, and even in her “Pow Wow Chow” cookbook recipes. (“Cold Omelets with Crab Meat.” In 1950s Oklahoma? Hmm.)
Besides Mr. Trump and his champions, those who have pressed her most publicly on this charade are African Americans. Radio talk-show host Charlamagne Tha God called Ms. Warren “the original Rachel Dolezal” and asked her, “Why’d you do that?”
It matters because her Democratic support has been stubbornly white and very left-wing. While most blacks do vote for Democrats in presidential races, they also tend to be conservatives.
This may explain Mr. Trump’s numbers. An unintentionally hilarious Politico headline last week proclaimed, “Overwhelming majority of black voters back any 2020 Democrat over Trump.” The story revealed this number as 85%.
For context, consider the following: George W. Bush got 9% of the black vote in 2000 and 11% in 2004; John McCain got 4% in 2008; Mitt Romney, 6% in 2012.
Mr. Trump won 8% in 2016, and now he’s at 15%? That’s bad news for whoever becomes the Democratic candidate.
And if it’s a white woman who cynically abused, for personal advancement, our country’s attempts to make amends for centuries of racism, will her deceit be ignored?
We’ll never know the names of true minorities (whether black, Hispanic or Native American) who merited a position but lost it to a blond, blue-eyed “Cherokee.”
Ms. Warren can only hope Mr. Trump overdoes the “Pocahontas” mockery.
The second myth she promotes (at times) is losing her job as a young teacher because she got pregnant. On other occasions, she has acknowledged that she didn’t have the necessary credentials, that the school offered to renew her contract anyway and that she left to stay home with her child. Which is it?
Ms. Warren will win over women who believe her story of discrimination. She’ll lose the trust of women who think she is fudging once again to earn victim points, and she’ll lose less-privileged men weary of dubious discrimination claims.
In swing states where working-class whites determine outcomes (like Pennsylvania and Michigan) and states with large black populations (like Georgia and South Carolina), Ms. Warren’s personal authenticity may be crucial.
If Mr. Trump proved anything in 2016, it’s that he can count electoral votes. As president, he remains an arrogant and ethically challenged reality TV host and real-estate mogul. He never pretended to be anything else.
If these two face each other in 2020, we’re in for a fascinating and likely bitter ride.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.