When the big billboard on the face of Mount Washington was erected in the 1930s, Pittsburgh was not famous for its beauty.

It was famous for industry, for the mills and factories that belched so much grime into the air that white-collar workers had to don fresh shirts at midday. Whatever beauty Pittsburgh possessed back then, no one could really see it.

Under such conditions, a cliffside billboard meant to be viewed from Downtown or all the way across the Ohio River was a pretty surprising investment. Who would pay for advertising space likely to be regularly obscured?

But my, how things have changed! In our postindustrial times. Pittsburgh is now internationally renowned for its beauty, for the charm, variety and historical richness of its buildings and bridges nestled so harmoniously amid rivers and wooded hillsides.

Advertise with us

Our compelling cityscape brings us pleasure. It brings plenty of tourists and media attention, too. All of these boost quality of life and broaden prosperity. So, however surprising the Mount Washington billboard was as a Depression-Era investment, it’s downright shocking today that its owner would use it to sabotage the city.

Since when is it a smart move for a company to stick its finger in its customers’ collective eye?

Since never, you’d think, but that’s the role Lamar Advertising has assumed ever since the Bayer Corp. abandoned its longstanding, low-key presence on the Mount Washington billboard.

The sign is now a heap of rusting metal; new technology makes it antiquated. Lots of us seem to prefer it like that. There’s certainly little clamor for a Vegas-style replacement.

Three years ago, in lieu of the digital monstrosity that is its goal, Lamar draped the metal hulk in a vinyl banner promoting Sprint. It was so aggressive and obnoxious that it ensured I will never patronize Sprint. Ever.

Advertise with us

Judging from my email inbox and letters to the editor, many were similarly repulsed. More significantly, the city decided to fight Lamar. The zoning board and law department became unusually creative and proactive, declared the banner a nonconforming use and ordered Lamar to remove it.

On Aug. 29, a Commonwealth Court panel dealt the Peduto administration a second setback, though, upholding the January 2018 decision of Common Pleas Judge Joseph James that reversed the zoning board’s order. Mayor Bill Peduto quickly vowed to appeal — the city did so on Sept. 19 — and keep fighting.

The mayor is right to do so. The city should continue its effort to prevent one property owner from visually monopolizing a cityscape that belongs to all of us.

As the owner of this piece of private property, Lamar has the right to develop and profit from it within the scope of the law. The ongoing conflict is, of course, over what exactly the law allows.

A few voices have complained about the city’s waste of money on this battle. But staff costs are staff costs, regardless of the task assigned. So the real question is whether this task is worthwhile.

Advertise with us

It is. The city’s responsibility is to represent the interests of all its citizens, among which Lamar, as a corporate entity, is merely one.

How the city goes about it, of course, matters tremendously. Maybe it’s time to gather major players — the heroic crew at Scenic Pittsburgh, foundation reps and some big-name artists and architects — to have a high-profile spitballing session.

There’s already an exciting level of support for a Hollywood-style sign or a sculpture park — just two of the ideas floating out there. Great minds might even be able to conjure a way for Lamar to sneak in some positive branding or — gasp — advertising.

Whatever happens on Mount Washington commands the eyes of the whole city and, on sports nights, the whole nation. It should not be a derelict relic of Pittsburgh’s past or some tacky, Anywhere-USA dreck. Pittsburgh deserves something unique and worthy of its ever-growing reputation.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.

Advertise with us