As you drive southwest on Route 28 into the city of Pittsburgh, you pass a massive retaining wall along the base of Troy Hill. Six large panels punctuate this expanse, featuring historic scenes compiled from old photographs and etched into the concrete.
One panel depicts Avery College, a black institution that once stood on Nash Street in old Allegheny City. Established in 1858 by a local philanthropist, by 1866, its trustees were courting a renowned black minister named Henry Highland Garnet to become its second president.
They were aiming high. At the time, Garnet’s star shone second only, perhaps, to Frederick Douglass among the nation’s black leadership. Just one year earlier, on Feb. 12, 1865, Garnet had made history as the first black minister to preach in the U.S. House of Representatives.
Somehow, four years ago, I missed the 150th anniversary of this sermon. My belated discovery of it last week, while researching Lincoln’s 1809 birth, led me to ponder how easily what’s good and true may slip from our memory, even something as pivotal as Henry Garnet and his historic sermon.
On Lincoln’s birthday he stood between portraits of Washington and Lafayette and called out our “national sin.” He cleaned House.
It’s strange to imagine now, but for decades after the nation’s founding, Christian services were held most Sundays in the House, in federal buildings, even in Supreme Court chambers. Presidents attended regularly, including Thomas Jefferson himself (a fact which illuminates what this champion of “the wall of separation” actually intended).
In fact, Jefferson and Aaron Burr were in a large crowd that heard a female evangelist at a January 1806 service, but it wasn’t until 1865 that a black man — Henry Garnet, pastor of Washington, D.C.’s Fifteenth Street Presbyterian Church and a former slave — would smash the race barrier. And how.
That Sunday, Feb. 12, was Abraham Lincoln’s 56th birthday. The House had just passed the 13th Amendment, to abolish slavery, on Jan. 31, 1865. To celebrate both these events, the chaplain of Congress invited Garnet to speak.
His sermon, “Let the Monster Perish,” still has the power to thrill. After denouncing — with devastating eloquence — the many crimes of slavery and the obvious hypocrisy of those who practiced it while considering themselves “just, humane, benevolent and Christian,” he challenged the nation to “emancipate, enfranchise [and] educate” all its citizens. Only then would the monster of slavery die.
It takes giants to slay monsters. Lincoln, Garnet and Douglass were giants. Others have graced our nation before and since, but the consequences of great evil may last for generations. And evil is a resilient shape-shifter.
We still wrestle with how well or poorly we are meeting Garnet’s 154-year-old challenge, just as great Americans battled slavery for centuries before this escaped slave rose to address Congress.
Roger Williams, an English theologian who founded the colony that became Rhode Island, advocated a “wall of separation between church and state” in the 1640s, the coining that Jefferson knowingly quoted 150 years later. An advocate for “liberty of conscience” far ahead of his time, Williams was one of America’s first abolitionists, helping pass a 1652 law prohibiting the enslavement of Africans.

The appetite for sugar and rum were stronger forces, though, and within years of Williams’ death, Rhode Island had more slaves than any other New England colony and was a major port in the transatlantic slave trade. His righteous legacy was undone.
The fight for freedom and justice has always been uphill. The more goodness we seek, the stronger pushback we can expect — an equal and opposite force.
Garnet led Pittsburgh’s Avery College for two years before returning to his first church in New York City. The Route 28 etching of that long-gone black school has a special coating to prevent its defacement. But if marred, then, like every good thing, it will have to be renewed.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.