There is a tug of war between hubris and humility in George Santayana’s aphorism: “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

The hubris lurks in the assumptions that “the past” was uniformly bad, that we will remember the past correctly and that, remembering, we will do better than our forebears.

There is humility in desiring to learn from history’s mistakes, but these days a judgmental arrogance seems to prevail. My collection of recent examples is growing quickly.

Santayana published his insight in 1905, well before the inane World War I kicked off a century-long spree of slaughter, totalitarianism, genocide, mass starvations, re-education camps, gulags and terrorism.

Advertise with us

That’s a history most humans would prefer not to repeat. One praiseworthy warrior against such horrors was Winston Churchill. But Churchill was, alas, insufficiently enlightened for today’s Twitterverse.

Daily news consumers probably remember last October when astronaut Scott Kelly approvingly quoted Churchill, who counseled, “In victory, magnanimity.” Churchill embodied Santayana’s adage: He remembered that the victors’ failure to be magnanimous after World War I led directly to World War II, making his and Harry Truman’s post-war leadership so crucial.

Tweets pilloried Mr. Kelly for praising Churchill, whose views on empire and race don’t measure up to modern morals. As soon as Mr. Kelly apologized, he was flogged by Churchill admirers, who aptly decried today’s criticisms as “generational chauvinism.”

It was therefore heartening to see Esquire, a reliably left-leaning magazine, recognize the Churchill kerfuffle in its end-of-year Dubious Achievements issue, with the “We Will Always Surrender” Award.

Another icon undergoing new scrutiny is Mohandas Gandhi. India’s liberator, who inspired Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela and Reinhold Niebuhr, among others, is now assailed for various conflicting failures: for being too tolerant of the Hindu caste system, but too kind toward minorities, but too racist against black Africans. Try untangling that knot.

Advertise with us

Martin Luther’s defiance of the Roman Catholic Church and his insistence on “the priesthood of the believer” sparked the Protestant Reformation and the rise of representative democracy. But if you praise him, you may well be assailed for overlooking his (late-in-life) anti-Semitism and his vulgar sense of humor. These are not minor matters (except for Luther’s vulgarity, which I find endearing), but what are wholesale, broad-brush condemnations about?

Some strike me as intellectual preening and attention-seeking. Some are “virtue-signaling,” displaying their own goodness by pointing out others’ flaws. (Maybe they’re auditioning to be columnists.)

The rush to denounce the past can foster real stupidity: Gilbert and Sullivan’s “The Mikado” is not an offensive “Orientalist enterprise,” as my favorite puzzle blogger and others claim; it was serious criticism of Britain’s class system made safe and stark by relocating it to what was then an exotic, little-known society. It’s called art.

At some level, these baby-with-the-bath-water attacks are about political power: It is ideologues and totalitarians, from Marx’s heirs to the Taliban, who deplore the past and dethrone its heroes. If they can make you ashamed of your culture, they’ve neutralized you.

They will be judged, perhaps by God, but certainly by history. All of us will, and we’ll all be found wanting. We should hope those who follow us have some mercy.

Advertise with us

By the way, Santayana’s history adage comes from “Reason in Common Sense.” In his following book, “Reason in Society,” he compared the human race to bees, claiming “the masculine soul is a worker, … essentially dedicated to impersonal and universal arts; the feminine is a queen, infinitely fertile, … abounding in intuitions without method and passions without justice.”

What a sexist jerk. No one should ever quote him again.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).