Sometimes a little quip reveals a deep chasm. So it was with that briefly notorious tweet from “The Late Show” writer Ariel Dumas. The critics who demanded her firing should instead thank her for the wake-up call.

As the confirmation vote for the newest Supreme Court justice unfolded last weekend, Ms. Dumas tweeted, “Whatever happens, I’m just glad we ruined Brett Kavanaugh’s life.”

She was echoing the judge’s impassioned plaint during the hearings: “I’m never going to get my reputation back. It’s — it — my life is totally and permanently altered.”

“Altered” was his word. “Ruined” came from New York Times opinion writer Roxane Gay, screenshots of whose column Ms. Dumas also tweeted. Said Ms. Gay: “The bar for a man’s ruin is, apparently, quite low. May we all be so lucky as to have our lives so ruined.”

Advertise with us

The backlash to Ms. Dumas was strong and quick. She deleted the comment and apologized for her “tone-deaf attempt at sarcasm,” adding, “The last few weeks have been hard for the country and for me personally.”

Whether she was being sarcastic or not hardly matters. If she were truly glad to have ruined someone’s life, she would be guilty of real hatred — her critics’ assumption.

If she was being sarcastic, then she is unable to comprehend that someone might be upset about having his reputation destroyed by hazy accusations of heinous crimes.

Either way, her remark and Ms. Gay’s come from minds with apparently little or no grasp on the importance of personal honor. They seem to believe the thing that matters most in life is professional success. Judge Kavanaugh has become Justice Kavanaugh, achieving the top spot in his chosen career, so all is well!

The reality is that these allegations will follow him to his grave. They will be recited in his obituary and brought up in any conversation about anyone related to him for decades.

Advertise with us

His primary accuser, Christine Blasey Ford, was pushed reluctantly from anonymity to notoriety and will be feted by some and scorned by others for the rest of her life.

Isn’t is possible to have walked away from the Kavanaugh hearings with sympathy for both of the main characters? Only an ideologue would not.

Ms. Dumas had previously tweeted, mid-hearings, that she was “emotionally shattered by the current state of affairs.” It’s strange that someone with so much emotion has no empathy for others’ pain.

Setting aside that mockery is the laziest, meanest form of humor, such jibes reveal either stunted souls or closed minds, whether uttered in Hollywood or Washington, D.C.

But I don’t believe the majority of Americans are hardened ideologues, not even those who identify with a political party. If too many of us have shrugged at or stoked partisan polarization, the Kavanaugh hearings surely have awakened us to the hideousness this leads to.

Advertise with us

The most important divide now isn’t over party. It’s over character.

Most people don’t crave fame or power so much that they forget the importance of personal integrity. Most people desire honor in their lives and honor in our government.

Sadly there is rot right at the top. Senator Dianne Feinstein behaved dishonorably in handling Ms. Ford’s accusation, from start to finish, and President Donald Trump erred (as is his habit) in mocking the judge’s accuser. Fair-minded people know this.

Fair-minded people also acknowledge that while Ms. Ford obviously suffered some kind of trauma in life, the presumption of innocence, the need for evidence and the rule of law demanded the less-than-satisfying outcome we got.

There’s a reason the ninth of the Ten Commandments says, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.” It’s because at the end of everything, our good name has more meaning than almost anything else.

Advertise with us

The effort to find truth in an imperfect world will often yield imperfect outcomes, but we must remain committed to trying and must display compassion for the effort’s victims — all of them.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com