Who would have guessed that a faith-based movement would vanquish feminism? And that it would do so in our increasingly secular age?
Yet it has — or is on the cusp of doing so.
Those whose new motto is “Believe Women” are destroying the very foundation on which feminism rests.
Although a surprising number of women decline to call themselves feminists, most of us operate our lives in tacit agreement with its core tenets. Feminism asserts that women are equal in value to men and should have the same rights and opportunities.
That we are, as a group, as smart, as talented and creative, as worthy to strive and achieve in any area we choose, as men are.
That the fact we have breasts and wombs does not make us weak or irrational and does not disqualify us from pursuits outside the home.
But is there anything more emotional and less reason-based than today’s call to “Believe Women”?
I am to believe all women no matter what? I must believe any woman’s story because some women have been doubted?
What if her story has inconsistencies and contradictions?
Just believe!
No matter what the evidence says? Just believe!
How injurious to a society based on the rule of law. How demeaning. How hysterical.
You can see real pain or anger in the faces of some who bear the “Believe Women” placards, badges and forearm scrawls. Some of this emotion is certainly legitimate; most of us, it seems, know a woman who has been the victim of a sexual indignity, assault or even rape.
But some of the anger, the whipping up, is clearly political cynicism. Our emotions — whether sister-feeling or anticipatory male guilt — are being manipulated to achieve one faction’s political ends.
I refuse to be manipulated like this or to stand silent as hysterics consume our national discourse, because I’m an adult woman with a brain, healthy boundaries and a civic duty.
When I was a little girl watching TV with my siblings, I often would run out of the room about two-thirds through any sitcom episode, too embarrassed by the star’s humiliating predicament to watch. I’d also flee if any show got really scary. My big sister would holler when it was safe to return.
Eventually I grew up and “put away childish things.” Every adult must come to know where she ends and someone else begins. What, in any given interaction, is her responsibility and what is on the other party.
Failure to develop this understanding makes life tougher to navigate. Bullies and users prowl along these boundaries, looking for weakness and seeking victims. Political bullies prowl there, too.
The “Believe Women” crowd has no room for conflicting facts, much less fine distinctions. It’s all or nothing. And this irresponsible anti-intellectualism has infected even our most vaunted institutions.
A case in point is the column titled “Make My Sexual Assault Count” by Mara Gay, in Monday’s New York Times, about “the boy who raped me”:
“I dated him afterward. Part of the encounter was consensual. We had both been drinking, him far more than me. I thought maybe he didn’t know what he was doing, and later didn’t remember …”
Watching Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh resonated with Ms. Gay’s experience. She concludes: “[I]t’s up to the men of this country to hear us. That is what we are owed, as citizens and as human beings.”
Well, listening to people’s stories is an important part of treating them as equals, but I don’t see how I or all of America can “make” anyone’s sexual assault “count.”
For those who demand personal validation on such a massive scale — “Believe Women!” — I sincerely wish they find healing, but it shouldn’t require the sacrifice of our system of law to assuage their pain.
Insisting we always believe women who make any accusations against men plays right into the old, harmful narrative that feminism is a vengeful, man-hating crusade. Or that women are too emotional and illogical to be men’s equals. Take your pick.
Something rights-focused movements usually neglect is that equal rights come with equal responsibilities. If activists can’t accept the responsibilities, then it isn’t “equal” rights they seek — it’s special treatment.
And that’s what we’re seeing here, in real time, played out in the Senate’s confirmation hearings. The Kavanaugh situation changes rapidly as new claims emerge, as facts are established.
I hope and pray that enough truth emerges to restore most Americans’ confidence in our justice system, but I’ll believe it when I see it.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.