Credibility, like trust and a good reputation, is hard to earn, easy to lose. It’s also ruinously expensive once it’s gone, especially in international relations. So it is no small matter that Donald Trump, eight months into his second term as U.S. president, has squandered whatever credibility America had left in foreign and security policy.

The latest embarrassments occurred last week, when Trump fired off several zingers on the same day, causing world leaders to be by turns shocked, puzzled or — most devastatingly — indifferent verging on bemused. In a rambling speech at the United Nations, Trump offended not only that institution, but countries from Brazil to Britain.

Reversals and blame

Later, he ad-libbed his latest reversal on the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine. Kyiv, he said, could “fight and WIN all of Ukraine back in its original form” because Russia is a “paper tiger.” This came a month after he rolled out, literally, the red carpet for Russian President Vladimir Putin; and after he first set, then shifted, then sheepishly dropped an ultimatum to Putin to enter ceasefire talks.

In the months before that, he had variously blamed Ukraine for its own invasion and claimed that Kyiv held “no cards” and had to cede territory.

Advertise with us

Putin seems to have concluded long ago that Trump is what the Soviet-era KGB used to call a “useful idiot.” Since Trump took office this year, he has not restrained but intensified his bombing of Ukraine, as well as his “gray-zone” operations against European NATO countries — all without incurring noticeable consequences from Washington.

In recent days, Russia even sent drones into Poland and Romania, fighter jets into Estonia, and apparently more drones into Scandinavia. Respect, fear and awe of Trump’s “strength” would look different.

Trump is hardly the first U.S. president in recent history to forfeit America’s credibility. Barack Obama, for example, once drew a red line to deter Syria’s Bashar al-Assad from using chemical weapons against his own people, then did nothing when the dictator did exactly that in 2013.

Allies now know they can’t trust America, while adversaries are ganging up and recalculating their plans for mischief or worse.

Necessary to deterrence

Credibility was and is the quintessence of deterrence. During the Cold War, credibility — in this case, the assurance of devastating retaliation against any atomic first strike — became the linchpin of the strategies and game theory that aimed to keep the East-West conflict from going nuclear. “Face is one of the few things worth fighting over,” said scholar Thomas Schelling.

Advertise with us

After the Cold War, argues Keren Yarhi-Milo, the dean of Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs, many policymakers concluded that “reputation may not be worth fighting for.” This was true especially after the debacles in Iraq and Afghanistan.

“Dropping bombs on someone to prove that you’re willing to drop bombs on someone is just about the worst reason to use force,” Obama said in an attempt to explain his failure in Syria — failing to grasp that other foes were now less likely to heed future American red lines.

In 2025, such fads seem passé again, as the deficit in American credibility appears to invite more aggression by geopolitical rivals or rogue nations. What Trump tried to sell as strength through the “madman theory” increasingly looks like weakness through whim, indecision and chaos.

Yarhi-Milo and Hillary Clinton (the two co-teach a course at Columbia) argue that he also deludes himself in thinking that personal chemistry, as he claims to have with Putin, can replace strategy and expertise in world affairs, and above all genuine resolve

Danger everywhere

Inklings of danger are everywhere. America’s partners are becoming more anxious and making alternative arrangements for their security: Saudi Arabia just signed a defensive pact with Pakistan after watching an Israeli strike against its Gulf neighbor Qatar, which is allied to, but got no help from, the United States.

Advertise with us

America’s adversaries keep testing the resolve of Trump and the West, as Putin is doing in eastern Europe. Or, like Xi Jinping in Beijing and Kim in Pyongyang, they’re recalculating bellicose scenarios in secret. Other countries, like India, are wary of committing to America and keeping all their options open, even clutching hands with Moscow and Beijing.

These responses to America’s loss of credibility will raise the risk of global conflict. The danger will go up even more if the U.S., under this or a future president, panics and decides to overcompensate in reestablishing its reputation, with a demonstratively hawkish turn that could tip into war.

If America and the whole world are becoming less safe, it’s because Donald Trump’s foreign policy is, literally, in-credible.

Andreas Kluth is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “Marco Rubo is helping make China great again.”