She had not seen the axe coming for her, one Foreign Service Officer told me, till one Friday morning she found a termination email in her inbox, signed by Lew Olowski, a MAGA firebrand who runs personnel at the State Department.

Despite years of stellar performance reviews and special assignments, she became one of roughly 1,350 people at the department, including about 250 FSOs, who got “RIFed,” as they call it (after the euphemism “reduction in force”).

In April, Secretary of State Marco Rubio promised to “drain the bloated, bureaucratic swamp” and rid the department of “radical ideologues.” But among those let go last week were experts on foreign-policy hotspots such as Ukraine.

A larger upheaval

The downsizing is itself part of a larger upheaval in America’s diplomacy. Rubio wants to cut the total budget for international affairs, including the department and its many programs, by 84%. He plans to slash or stop funding to parts of the United Nations and other multilateral organizations.

Advertise with us

He’s already shuttered the United States Agency for International Development, subsuming a few of its functions in the department but leaving a gaping global hole in efforts to contain AIDS, malaria, starvation and other ills in poor countries. He’s all but taken America’s overseas broadcasters off the air, from the Voice of America to Radio Liberty.

And he’s joined in as the administration of Donald Trump harasses foreign students at America’s elite universities, scaring away the next generation of global leaders and talent.

Never has a country blessed with such an abundance of “soft power” forfeited so much of it with so little justification. One rationale given by the administration and its partisans is the same that ostensibly inspired the “DOGE-ing” of other government agencies: the need to end waste.

Of course there was some fat within State, USAID and the other programs. But why whip out a chainsaw instead of a scalpel?

Other attacks on these organs of diplomacy seem unhinged. Brian Mast, who chairs the House Foreign Affairs Committee, has been hyperbolizing that USAID specialized in taking tax dollars from hard-working Americans to buy condoms for the Taliban, and that the US Agency for Global Media, which funded broadcasters like Voice of America, is a “a cesspool of spies, lies and mismanagement” that says nasty things about Trump and must therefore be anti-American.

Advertise with us

Incalculable goodwill

The truth is that USAID has saved many, many lives — about 92 million in a 21-year span, according to the British medical journal The Lancet. And VoA and the other global broadcasters brought American-accented but independent news to people in countries friendly and hostile, democratic and authoritarian. Both spread incalculable goodwill, even if they weren’t always run as efficiently as one would wish.

Critics of this wholesale onslaught can take two tacks. Idealists tend to respond with moral indignation about the immense human suffering caused around the world by, say, the gutting of USAID. The Lancet estimates that its absence, and the resulting increase in disease and malnutrition, will cause 14 million additional deaths by 2030, including more than 4 million deaths of young children.

These arguments, though, do nothing to move MAGA types and often backfire. After all, those numbers do not refer to dead Americans, and Trump is all about putting America First. Why should US taxpayers save the world? Fair point.

Realists ask a different question: Does this diplomatic revolution in fact put America First and Make America Great Again? The answer is no, according to Jeanne Shaheen, the ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. Instead, she says, it will have the effect of making China great.

A 91-page report commissioned by Shaheen details all parts of America’s diplomatic “retreat” and concludes that it “deeply undermined US competitiveness vis-a-vis China.” Wherever America steps down or out, China steps up or in: Whether it’s with more propaganda; new missions and consulates; more clout at the World Health Organization, the International Telecommunications Union and other multilateral bodies; or more university spots for refugees from the new American brain drain.

Advertise with us

Everybody, Republican and Democrat alike, hates bloat and likes efficiency. The question is whether that is the only motive driving the turmoil at State.

MAGA’s culture war

Those affected, like the FSO I talked to, suspect that Foggy Bottom, like the Pentagon, is instead in the throes of a MAGA culture war with the ultimate goal of politicizing American statecraft.

At an internal townhall gathering the other day, she heard Olowski demand that the department screen applicants for patriotism. Her first thought, she told me, was: Of course, we’re all patriotic; that’s why we’re here. Her second thought was: Wait, what does patriotism look like to him? Because maybe it doesn’t look like me.

When such anxieties and doubts colonize the minds of America’s diplomats, who often sacrifice for their country as much as military families do, the State Department has reached a dangerous juncture. So has the United States.

Andreas Kluth is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “The president doesn't know if the bombing of Iran succeeded.”