Carl Schmitt was the Nazi Party’s favorite legal scholar. Antonio Gramsci was a leading Marxist intellectual imprisoned by Mussolini. Samuel Francis was a maverick intellectual who spent his life hanging around on the fringes of power in Washington in the Reagan-Bush-Clinton era.
But, united by their fierce contempt for liberalism, they were all dangerous minds who have assumed a new importance in the MAGA era. If you want to understand the full significance of MAGA, you need to engage them. Our three intellectuals prefigured the dynamics of the MAGA movement before it was born.
Schmitt and hard power
In their separate ways, they produced blueprints for the destruction of liberalism that can be applied wherever anti-liberals seize power.
Carl Schmitt’s blueprint is the most terrifying, given his complicity in Hitler’s rise. He took aim at the central liberal belief that politics is about discussion and compromise. Sometimes he saw discussion as a sign of weakness and sometimes he saw it as a smokescreen for the machinations of interest groups. But his hatred was fierce.
He said that the point of power is to make decisions. The legislature must defer to the executive and the executive to the leader. He insisted that the primal political division is between “friends” and “enemies.” The job of politicians is to find enemies and destroy them, not to cherish opponents and compromise with them.
He believed that in “emergencies,” the most important power is the power to suspend the normal rules of political life and declare a “state of exception,” suspending the laws to save the state. “Sovereign is he who decides on the exception,” he said.
Trump-friendly intellectuals are increasingly willing to refer directly to Schmitt’s influence even though he never renounced his Nazi past or his antisemitism. This is partly because academics on both the left and the right have taken to re-reading him. Adrian Vermeule, a lonely Trump-friendly professor at Harvard Law School and an advocate of a maximalist interpretation of presidential power, frequently refers to him, for example.
Gramsci and soft power
If Schmitt believed that the only power that mattered was hard power, Gramsci focused on soft power. He argued that the ruling class ruled less by force than by cultural “hegemony.” It persuaded the masses to accept the current order as not just inevitable but fitting.
Conservatives have long believed that the progressive left engineered a soft revolution in the U.S. by taking over the universities and other elite cultural institutions. Now they are engaged in a counter-revolution designed to do for MAGA what the left intelligentsia did for the Democratic Party.
“The right needs a Gramsci,” activist Christopher Rufo once told the Wall Street Journal. He started his career by trying to dismantle DEI programs, and by calling for the defunding of left-leaning cultural institutions such as PBS and NPR. Now he encourages universities to re-embrace a more traditional curriculum.
MAGA activists want to create a counter-elite who can continue to remodel American culture, not just American politics, long after Trump has left the White House.
Francis and nationalist power
Samuel Francis was a less weighty figure than the other two. He was also a member of a familiar but unfortunate Washington sub-species: the slightly seedy monomaniac who accosts you over a sandwich lunch at a think tank and gives you the benefit of his views on everything under the sun.
He ended in disgrace — marginalized even from the margin — because of his racial obsessions. But he was nevertheless arguably the first person to see the power of national greatness conservatism to reorder the Republican coalition.
Francis identified a new revolutionary force in American politics: Middle American Radicals, or the white ethnics who made up the country’s silent majority of working stiffs. These people had been driven out of the Democratic Party by its new coalition of educated elites (who looked down on them) and poor ethnic minorities (who rejected their bourgeois values).
They briefly found a home in the Republican Party as “Reagan Democrats.” But the Republicans then betrayed them in favor of creating global supply chains and playing the global police officer — what Francis regarded as the twin evils of neoconservatism and neoliberalism.
He had a clear solution to the problem: Pursue a policy of national greatness based on tariffs, immigration restrictions and military retrenchment and put working-class white ethnics rather than country club Republicans at the heart of a new coalition. The sharper the break with the neoconservatives and the neoliberals, and the louder the cries from ethnic minorities and cosmopolitan elites, including the “globalist” national-security bureaucracy, the better.
Their disturbing program
The odd thing about this odd trio is how neatly their ideas fit together into a coherent, not to mention disturbing, political program.
Schmitt’s politics of emergencies provides a mechanism for driving radicalism ever forward, as does his politics of friends versus enemies. Gramsci’s theory of hegemony transforms regime change into a wider cultural change. Francis’ Middle Americans provide a social basis as well as a nationalist crucible for populist policies.
All three men once dreamed of different ways of destroying their greatest enemy, liberalism. Now they are engaged in a surprisingly successful collaboration in liberalism’s natural home and greatest creation.
Adrian Wooldridge is the global business columnist for Bloomberg Opinion and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.” His previous article was “Breeding better children: the new tech-driven eugenics.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.