The latest Silicon Valley fashion is for tech investors to fund fertility start-ups such as Orchid Health, which proclaims, “Sex is for fun, and embryo screening is for babies.” The latest billionaire status symbol is a quiver full of children: Elon Musk has more than a dozen and Peter Thiel, a late starter, reportedly has four. The plot of a new science-fiction series, “Alien: Earth,” features trillionaires who compete to produce the best super-humans.

Most people associate eugenics with Hitler’s mad scheme to breed an Aryan super-race and liquidate the Jewish people. Yet his version of eugenics was only an extreme version of a faith that was pervasive in the West from 1880 to 1945.

A popular faith

It was a faith that was as popular in the Anglo-Saxon world as the Teutonic one and as popular on the progressive left as the nationalist right. The term was invented by an Englishman, Sir Francis Galton, by putting together two Greek words, “eu” (“good”) and “gene” (“origin” or “birth”).

In those years, enthusiasm for eugenics was almost universal among Anglo-Saxon intellectuals left, right or center, with the exception of Roman Catholics such as G.K. Chesterton. Nationalists such as Karl Pearson, the English founder of the discipline of statistics, regarded the quality of the population as a vital dimension of national power.

Advertise with us

Centrists such as the economist J.M. Keynes regarded improving the population as a necessary dimension of general social improvement. Socialists such as H. G. Wells and George Bernard Shaw believed in the “socialization for the selective breeding of man.” Even the liberal gadfly Bertrand Russell argued that the state should provide everyone with colored “procreation tickets” and come down hard on people who fraternized with the wrong color-ticket.

Eugenicists distinguished between “positive” eugenics (encouraging the “right” people to reproduce) and “negative” eugenics (discouraging the “wrong” people from reproducing)

Eugenics drew on two of the period’s most powerful feelings: optimism in the ability of science to solve intractable problems and pessimism about the deterioration of the population. Eugenicists dreamed of eliminating genetic problems such as “mental deficiency” and thereby reducing crime and poverty.

They also worried that Darwin’s mighty force — the survival of the fittest — was going into reverse thanks to the higher likelihood of “the better sort of people” availing themselves of contraception. In 1934 the demographer Enid Charles published a vivid book entitled “The Twilight of Parenthood.”

Driven by science and ideology

The eugenics movement was driven as much by the spirit of scientific problem-solving as racist ideology. Leading universities such as University College, London, had chairs of eugenics. Birth-control pioneers such as Margaret Sanger and Marie Stopes tried to liberate women from unwanted pregnancies.

Advertise with us

Eugenicists were forever coming up with technical innovations such as IQ tests or intellectual breakthroughs such as the theory of polygenetic inheritance.

The current revival of eugenics echoes almost every feature of the pre-war movement: It is taking place across the political spectrum, drawing on fears about population decline as well as hopes about eliminating terrible diseases, and advancing through incremental problem-solving more than political agitation.

Today’s eugenics draws on the same mixture of optimism and pessimism as the pre-war variety. Optimism about the power of genetics to “optimize” the species. Pessimism about the advanced world’s hostility to the basic biological imperative of reproducing the species. A growing school of pro-natalists warns that falling birth rates will lead to economic and civilizational collapse.

Today’s eugenics is also driven, like its predecessor, by incremental scientific progress. Genetic screening allows parents to test embryos for a wide range of genetic predispositions. Orchid will provide you with a polygenic risk score for $2,200 per embryo.

When parents start availing themselves of genetic advantages, others will feel obliged to do likewise, such is the pressure of the rat race. If the rich freely avail themselves of genetic screening, pressure will mount for the state (or employers) to provide it for the rest of us.

Advertise with us

Tsvi Benson-Tilsen, the co-founder of the Berkeley Genomics Project, argues that humanity may have to breed smarter humans to prevent Artificial Intelligence from running out of control.

Morals and commerce

The moral defenses against the misuse of genetics are weaker today than they were before the Second World War, thanks to the waning of Christianity. Today’s commercial forces are far more powerful than they were in the old days. Companies are competing to push the envelope on “optimization”: Startups such as Nucleus Genomics and Herasight are going further than Orchid by offering IQ predictions, based on genetic tests.

The growing competition between China and the US also adds a worrying element to all this: What if a rival great power puts its muscle behind breeding superior humans? The Chinese state has already conditioned its people to accept population engineering, through its one-child policy and the sterilization of selected Uighurs.

The government even passed a Eugenics and Health Protection Law forbidding people with mental and physical disorders from having children. It later abandoned the word “eugenic” though not the policy.

Now there are signs that it is experimenting with genetic engineering to produce higher-quality citizens. “Drone warfare will seem quaint if we are faced with genetically enhanced PLA super-soldiers with fused human and artificial intelligence,” warns a recent report from the US National Security Commission on Emerging Biotechnology.

Advertise with us

All of which raises an inevitable question: What are the chances that the current vogue will morph into a nightmare in the same way that the previous vogue did?

Adrian Wooldridge is the global business columnist for Bloomberg Opinion and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.” His previous article was “American business isn't woke. It's designed to be mediocre.”