In the year since the at­tacks by Ha­mas against Is­raeli ci­vil­ians on Oct. 7, 2023, much has changed, and the war seems like a wa­ter­shed mo­ment that could serve as the event that fi­nally cat­a­lyzes a last­ing trans­for­ma­tion for the re­gion.

But in another way, little has changed. President Joe Biden’s administration remains firm in its commitment to aiding Israel militarily and its continued support reflects a long-standing bipartisan consensus in Washington to see Israel as a strong, and at times lone, ally of the United States in the region.

But the view of the Amer­i­can pub­lic to­ward both Is­rael and the Pal­es­tin­ians has re­mained much the same a year af­ter Oct 7. This might be sur­pris­ing, given the wide­spread at­ten­tion over the past year to pro­tests on and off col­lege cam­puses, city coun­cils across the U.S. call­ing for a cease-fire and a gen­eral sense that the U.S.-Is­rael “spe­cial re­la­tion­ship” is at a turn­ing point.

Ac­cord­ing to new sur­vey data pro­duced by The Pear­son In­sti­tute and The As­so­ci­ated Press-NORC Center for Pub­lic Af­fairs Re­search, pub­lic views on the Is­raeli-Pal­es­tin­ian con­flict are rel­a­tively static.

Advertise with us

Is­rael about right

A sur­vey con­ducted last No­vem­ber, one month into the cur­rent war in Gaza, found that only 40% of American adults saw Is­rael’s mil­i­tary re­sponse as hav­ing “gone too far.” Given the many pro­tests, as well as as­sess­ments by the State Depart­ment re­gard­ing Is­rael’s lack of safe­guards for non­com­bat­ants, one might ex­pect that num­ber to have changed over the past year.

It has — but mar­gin­ally. A poll con­ducted in Sep­tem­ber put the num­ber at 42% of re­spon­dents. This means that a ma­jor­ity of re­spon­dents in both polls saw Is­rael’s re­sponse as “about right” or as hav­ing “not gone far enough.”

Sim­i­larly, views re­gard­ing U.S. sup­port to­ward Is­rael have re­mained largely static. In No­vem­ber of last year, 43% of re­spon­dents re­sponded that the U.S. pro­vided “too much” aid to Is­rael. In Sep­tem­ber of this year, that num­ber dropped mar­gin­ally to 41%. But these num­bers do not sim­ply re­flect a strong pro-Is­rael sen­ti­ment among the Amer­i­can pub­lic.

The sur­veys found a sim­i­lar sta­bil­ity in sup­port for aid­ing the Pal­es­tin­ians. In No­vem­ber, only 29% of re­spon­dents thought the U.S. was pro­vid­ing “too much” hu­man­i­tar­ian re­lief to the Pal­es­tin­ians in Gaza. That num­ber dropped to 24% of re­spon­dents in Sep­tem­ber.

Sym­pa­thy for both sides

Related to these num­bers, feel­ings of sym­pa­thy to­ward the sides have re­mained sta­ble, with slight in­creases from No­vem­ber to Sep­tem­ber in sym­pa­thy to­ward Is­rael (21% to 25%) and the Pal­es­tin­ians (9% to 15%).

Advertise with us

The sur­vey as a whole seems to cap­ture how the in­her­ent com­plex­ity of the con­flict makes it dif­fi­cult for Amer­i­cans to have a uni­fied and con­sis­tent view on the mat­ter. They may have sym­pa­thy for the Is­raeli peo­ple, but, like Biden, see the Is­raeli prime min­is­ter as an im­ped­i­ment to peace. They are sad­dened by the plight of the Pal­es­tin­ians but ap­palled by the ac­tions of Ha­mas.

This con­trasts with Western per­cep­tions, and spe­cif­i­cally Amer­i­can per­spec­tives, re­gard­ing the war in Ukraine, where the ag­gres­sor, Rus­sia, and the de­fender, Ukraine, are clear, the com­plex­ity of the Is­rael-Pal­es­tin­ian re­la­tion­ship in gen­eral and the war in Gaza in par­tic­u­lar leads to such sta­bil­ity of in­con­sis­tent views.

A war-weary pub­lic

The sur­vey num­bers could also sim­ply re­flect a gen­eral mal­aise, a war wea­ri­ness among the Amer­i­can pub­lic. While the United States is not a di­rect and full par­tic­i­pant in any of the nu­mer­ous con­flicts pres­ently en­gulf­ing the world, the most since the end of World War II, it is a sup­porter that is fund­ing and arm­ing var­i­ous states and ac­tors in­volved in these many con­flicts.

Un­for­tu­nately for the pub­lic, while it might have grown tired of this world of wars, the rag­ing of those wars is one trend that is un­likely to change be­tween now and next Oc­to­ber.

Paul Poast is an as­so­ci­ate pro­fes­sor in the de­part­ment of po­lit­i­cal sci­ence at the Univer­sity of Chi­cago.