Gaza is the Democrats’ Vietnam, 2024 their 1968. As the Democratic vice president, Hubert Humphrey, running for president in 1968, supported President Lyndon Johnson’s Vietnam War, the Democratic vice president, Kamala Harris, supports President Biden’s fueling of the Gaza War.
And just as a critical mass of anti-war Democrats who stayed home cost Humphrey the ’68 election to Richard Nixon, an anti-war critical mass that stays home or votes for Jill Stein or Cornel West — could bring Harris defeat in November.
Nothing said for Gaza
As they had at the party’s 1968 Chicago convention, anti-war protestors last month marched through the city. Unmoved by this street democracy, Democrats refused — presumably with Harris’s approval — to allow Palestinian-Americans to have a voice at the podium.
A word critical of Israel in Gaza was not allowed. Why would the Democratic candidate hold to a policy that could cost her progressive votes, a loss she can’t afford in so tight an election? Why does the Washington of which she’s a part fuel Israel’s Gaza War?
At least three reasons.
For starters, the ossification consequent to D.C. office-holding calcifies their critical thinking abilities. Our decision-makers cave to AIPAC and the war industry lobbyists who bankroll their campaigns.
Read More
Second, and insidiously, D.C. decision-makers conflate the Judeo-Christian heritage with today’s State of Israel. Even though both the prophet Jeremiah, in his judgments against the kings of Judah, and Jesus Christ, in his words on the invisible Kingdom of God, sharply distinguished the secular realm from that of the divine.
Third, shared myths and legacies glue Washington to Israel. Israel’s war on the Palestinians matches the United States’ legacy of war against the indigenous.
Invading westward, 19th century Americans likened removal of Indigenous nations to biblical Israel’s removal of the Canaanites from the “Promised Land.”
Mt. Rushmore in the Great Sioux Nation’s sacred Black Hills is Manifest Destiny’s monument, said the late Australian art critic Robert Hughes. To which I will add that Pine Ridge Indian Reservation is the Oglala Lakota Nation’s Gaza Strip.
Our two manifest destinies
During the Civil War General James Carleton’s United States Army troops out in New Mexico Territory waged Gaza type wars of annihilation against the Diné (Navajo) nation and the various Apache nations. Destroying the Diné base and orchards in Canyon de Chelly, Carleton forced upon the Diné the four-hundred-mile Long Walk into exile at desolate Bosque Redondo.
In an 1862 campaign against the Mescalero Apache, Carleton ordered that “All Indian men of that tribe are to be killed whenever and wherever you can find them.” Among the atrocities in Carleton’s campaigns was the army’s bayonet torture, shooting, scalping, and beheading, of 70-year-old Mimbreño Apache Chief Mangas Coloradas.
For this saga of destruction my students’ American history textbook “The Enduring Vision” can but supply the uplifting chapter title, “Transformation of the American West 1860-1900.” The dualism of “civilization” versus “savage” that drove destruction of the west back then keeps the textbook’s American authors from choosing a title describing what happened.
Tellingly, it is from a non-American historian, the Finnish historian Janne Lahti, author of “Wars for Empire: Apaches, the United States, and the Southwest Borderlands,” that I got my knowledge of Carleton’s Apache campaigns.
Palestinians’ October 7th attacks, cruel and stupid, massacred Israelis who were among the Palestinians’ staunchest advocates, inevitable blowback destroying Gaza. The Israeli Defense Force’s Gaza War, cruel and stupid, sows seeds that will reap unending harvests of vengeance.
The United States Army won its wars of Manifest Destiny. The Indigenous nations were too dispersed, too distinct, with numbers too few, settler millions too many.
The Israeli Defense Force cannot win its war. Palestinians are too concentrated, too united, with numbers too great, 1948 Naqba and 1967 taking of Gaza, East Jerusalem, and West Bank too resonant.
Democratic doom
The Gaza War is a failed front of Manifest Destiny’s 21st century descendant, the “rules based global order” for which President Biden has been lead salesperson.
Kamala Harris’s clinging to her president’s Gaza War, her inability to break with the United States' legacy of war against the indigenous, could spell Democratic doom November 5th.
Fred Jordan has taught world history at Nashville State Community College in Nashville, Tenn., since 1999.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.