Kari Lake’s ap­pear­ance at Ari­zona State Univer­sity last week was billed as a town hall, but it wasn’t re­ally, be­cause only rep­re­sen­ta­tives of young con­ser­va­tive groups were per­mit­ted to ask her any­thing.

Only one ques­tion, from Dan­ise Rees, pres­i­dent of the cam­pus chap­ter of Stu­dents for Life, was at all chal­leng­ing.

Two years ago, Lake called Ari­zona’s 1864 abor­tion ban a “great law.” But last month, af­ter a court rul­ing up­hold­ing the stat­ute gen­er­ated wide­spread out­rage, she came out against it, and even lob­bied Re­pub­li­cans to re­peal it.

Rees wanted clar­ity about where Lake stood. “Can you please de­fine your val­ues and tell us how you will rem­edy the doubts that pro-lif­ers have in you right now?” she asked.

Advertise with us

She echoed Trump

Lake echoed Don­ald Trump on the need for ex­cep­tions in cases of rape and in­cest, which the Ari­zona ban doesn’t have. She sug­gested that if Re­pub­li­cans let the law stand, it would fuel lib­eral ef­forts to pass a bal­lot ini­tia­tive en­shrin­ing abor­tion rights in the state con­sti­tu­tion.

But the core of her ar­gu­ment was electabil­ity. “There’s so much on the line this elec­tion,” she said. “We’re ei­ther go­ing to save our coun­try, or the Dem­o­crats — I call them Com­mu­nists — are go­ing to drive us right to the ground.” Given the ex­is­ten­tial stakes, Re­pub­li­cans can’t let them­selves get “caught up” with wedge is­sues like this one.

It was a cu­ri­ous ar­gu­ment com­ing from Lake, who later of­fered a so­lil­o­quy against com­pro­mis­ing the con­ser­va­tive move­ment’s prin­ci­ples. But it was a sign of how dif­fi­cult it has been for the Re­pub­li­can Party to bal­ance its base’s de­mand for abor­tion bans with the pub­lic re­vul­sion when those pol­i­cies are en­acted.

Eight years ago, many Chris­tian con­ser­va­tives put aside their qualms about Trump in the hope that he would lay the ground­work for out­law­ing abor­tion. It was a bar­gain that paid off, at least in the me­dium term.

But to­day, in pur­plish parts of the coun­try like Ari­zona, that po­lit­i­cal equa­tion is be­ing turned on its head, as some on the right ar­gue that they must put aside qualms about abor­tion so Re­pub­li­cans can win elec­tions.

Advertise with us

Just this week, Ari­zona re­pealed its sweep­ing 1864 ban, a law that Trump said went too far and would be “straight­ened out.” It was the first state with a Re­pub­li­can leg­is­la­ture to back off its most dra­co­nian abor­tion re­stric­tions since the fall of Roe.

In Ne­vada, Sam Brown, a long­time abor­tion op­po­nent run­ning for Senate, has come out against a na­tional abor­tion ban. In Feb­ru­ary he gave a TV in­ter­view with his wife in which she spoke about the abor­tion she had be­fore they met.

Eric Hovde, a Re­pub­li­can Senate can­di­date in Wis­con­sin, once de­clared him­self “to­tally op­posed to abor­tion.” Now he says women should have a “right to make a choice” early in preg­nancy.

The abor­tion ban party

The Re­pub­li­can Party is still very much the party of abor­tion bans. This week, Flor­ida be­gan pro­hib­it­ing the pro­ce­dure at six weeks. In an in­ter­view with Time mag­a­zine, Trump said he wouldn’t try to stop states from pros­e­cut­ing women who have had abor­tions, and re­fused to say whether he would veto a na­tional abor­tion ban.

If he wins in No­vem­ber, con­ser­va­tives have plans to use the Com­stock Act, a fed­eral law from the same era as the Ari­zona ban, to re­strict abor­tion na­tion­wide.

Advertise with us

Idaho is al­ready in the Supreme Court fight­ing the fed­eral gov­ern­ment’s at­tempts to make emer­gency rooms treat women with fail­ing preg­nan­cies be­fore they’re on the verge of death. And in Lou­i­si­ana, where al­most all abor­tion is il­le­gal, law­mak­ers are mov­ing to crim­i­nal­ize the mere pos­ses­sion of abor­tion pills.

Still, in swing states, Re­pub­li­can Party lead­ers are try­ing to dis­tance them­selves from the anti-abor­tion move­ment, treat­ing it much the way skit­tish Dem­o­crats once treated the move­ment for abor­tion rights. Back in the 1990s, Dem­o­crats re­lied on pro-choice votes, but haunted by old taunts about rep­re­sent­ing “acid, am­nesty and abor­tion,” they held ac­tiv­ists at a re­move.

Their lead­ers of­ten ex­pressed ei­ther dis­ap­proval or am­biv­a­lence about ter­mi­nat­ing preg­nan­cies. Bill Clin­ton ve­toed anti-abor­tion leg­is­la­tion and put pro-choice judges on the Supreme Court, but he also said the pro­ce­dure should be “safe, le­gal and rare.” As late as 2005, Hil­lary Clin­ton called abor­tion a “sad, even tragic choice.”

Now, how­ever, the Demo­cratic Party is united in cham­pi­on­ing abor­tion rights, with the vice pres­i­dent re­cently mak­ing his­tory by vis­it­ing an abor­tion clinic. It re­mains to be seen whether anti-abor­tion forces can ac­cli­mate to their new sta­tus as the em­bar­rass­ing step­chil­dren of a co­a­li­tion that once cod­dled them.

No choice for pro-lif­ers

After Lake’s event, Rees said she was dis­ap­pointed in Re­pub­li­cans. “I don’t think that it’s fair to ex­pect pro-lif­ers to show up for you the sec­ond time around when you com­pletely take a hands-off ap­proach on pro-life is­sues,” she said.

Advertise with us

Still, she rec­og­nized that peo­ple like her don’t have an­other choice. “I think there’s go­ing to be prob­a­bly other rea­sons why pro-lif­ers go out to vote,” she said, “but I think it’s go­ing to be a very re­luc­tant vote.”

Michelle Goldberg is a columnist for The New York Times. Her previous article was “‘Civil War’ is a frighteningly plausible movie.”