Having grown up in a Christian fundamentalist subculture and having now spent more than 50 years sifting through the consequences of that experience, I find this moment in American life nearly surreal.
To suddenly be surrounded by a new, more aggressive form of fundamentalism is ironic, but the fact that it’s mostly practiced by people who use the word “fundamentalist” as a pejorative stretches irony to the breaking point.
These extremists may not recognize the name “Jesus” except as a curse word, but many are fundamentalists, nonetheless. The ones I grew up amongst were much kinder people than the new version. They wanted to live their way and just be left alone.
Today’s fundamentalists have more in common with the Spanish Inquisition. Anyone who believes differently than they do is a “threat to democracy.” Those who refuse to become enlightened must be doxxed and canceled, their employment terminated, their homes picketed, their children harassed.
Secular fundamentalists will use the weight of the law to force conformity to their way of thinking. No Christian group has tried this in America since the days of the Massachusetts Bay Colony.
People tend to use the term “fundamentalist” incorrectly, as if it merely indicated excessive religious devotion. A friend who enjoys home renovation shows recently commented she wouldn’t watch Chip and Joanna Gaines because they’re “too fundamentalist.”
Read More
The Gaineses are not “fundamentalists” — not by a country mile. They are “evangelicals,” a term that has been tragically corrupted (as many things have) by the Trump presidency. Getting the terms straight is useful, because the two groups’ differences provide a fascinating take on today’s zeitgeist.
Briefly explained, “fundamentalism” arose in the early 1900s as a response to the “modernists” — theologians and pastors ensconced in posh, historic pulpits or Ivy League seminaries who began to deny the deity of Christ, scoff at a literal Resurrection, and so on. They were too educated to believe such things.
Those who outspokenly embraced the fundamentals of the faith and — this is key — refused to associate with “faith deniers” were called fundamentalists. They “separated” from the worldly compromisers.
Those who embraced core beliefs but tried to stay in amicable communion with all professing Christians eventually came to be known as evangelicals. I think their go-in-peace style is the antidote to America’s angry divisions.
Fundamentalism was largely spent by the 1980s. My parents’ generation — Christians who didn’t smoke, drink, dance, go to the movies, gamble, play cards, or let women wear pants — now have grown children who sport jeans at church, host poker nights and compare their wine cellars and favorite cigars.
In Christendom, fundamentalism’s only remaining bright line is sex. While some conservative churches exclude gays and espouse ardent pro-life beliefs, left-leaning people and churches disassociate from any that don’t embrace pro-choice activism, same-sex marriage or the latest in transgender ideology.
Caught in the middle, I have experienced the conservatives as stern and sorrowful, while the leftists are stern and remarkably haughty.
Outside the Christian world, zealotry drives some on both left and right. Anti-abortion purists pass laws that allow no exceptions and extend no mercy, not even to 10-year-old rape victims, while leftists force corporations to accept Marxist thinking and highly racist “anti-racist” policies, complete with re-education camps in the workplace. Attendance is mandatory — just like prayer in the public schools used to be.
We humans rarely recognize our own illiberal ways.
Fundamentalism may start with admirable goals — the desire to live with a clear conscience, to seek justice, to protect the vulnerable, to alleviate suffering — but zeal can so easily morph into coercion.
When you try to accomplish through laws and rules what you’ve failed to achieve through loving example and persuasion, it will backfire, eventually, to shocking effect.
When I encountered evangelicalism in the early 1980s, just as fundamentalism was waning, my heart was immediately won by the motto used so often in its unruly ranks:
“In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity.”
When people mourn the loss of bipartisan spirit, this is what they miss. Most Americans actually agree on the essentials, on “liberty and justice for all.” We disagree, as always, about how to achieve this but wish we could once again argue in good faith and share a friendly drink at day’s end.
The truth seems to be dawning that today’s savage secular fundamentalists won’t get us there.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.