The U.S. Cen­sus will now al­low for the use of a sin­gle “check all that ap­ply” race/​eth­nic­ity ques­tion with op­tions for La­tino/​His­panic and Mid­dle Eastern/​North African. This is a mon­u­men­tal step for­ward in ad­vanc­ing data eq­uity, not just for these groups, but for our abil­ity to ac­cu­rately com­pare U.S. ra­cial groups more broadly.

For de­cades, the U.S. cen­sus has main­tained sep­a­rate ques­tions for La­tino or­i­gin and race, forc­ing Lati­nos to choose from race op­tions such as white, Black, Amer­i­can In­dian, Asian and “other.” Unable to fit them­selves into these cat­e­go­ries, in 2020, nearly 44% of Lati­nos ei­ther did not an­swer the race ques­tion or marked “other.”

In fact, 94% of “other” race re­sponses to the cen­sus were Lati­nos. And “other” be­came the sec­ond-larg­est ra­cial group in the coun­try in 2020.

“Other” isn’t a race

But ac­cord­ing to fed­eral guide­lines, “other” is not a race. And when the Cen­sus Bureau then cre­ates pop­u­la­tion es­ti­mates, they have to re­al­lo­cate ab­sent or “other” re­sponses into ex­ist­ing ra­cial cat­e­go­ries. This trans­lates into nearly half of Lati­nos hav­ing a race as­signed for them, and in that pro­cess most have been re­clas­si­fied as white.

Advertise with us

As one can imag­ine, hav­ing half the ra­cial data for your com­mu­nity lit­er­ally made up has led to in­cred­i­bly poor qual­ity ra­cial data for Lati­nos. But it also means our coun­try’s “white” cat­e­gory has in­cluded peo­ple who do not iden­tify as white in it, which af­fects our abil­ity to look crit­i­cally at ra­cial dis­par­i­ties. Differ­ences among ra­cial groups have been muted some­what by the in­clu­sion of Lati­nos in the white cat­e­gory who don’t see them­selves as white and are likely not seen as white by oth­ers.

To be clear, there are Lati­nos who iden­tify ra­cially as white, Black, Asian or In­dig­e­nous. But there are many — ap­prox­i­mately 70%, based on the Cen­sus Bureau’s test­ing of the new ques­tion de­sign — who do not see them­selves in these cat­e­go­ries and pre­fer “La­tino” alone to de­scribe their race.

The de­sire for a “La­tino” op­tion is rooted in cur­rent and his­tor­i­cal re­al­i­ties. There is a long-stand­ing his­tory of ra­cial­iza­tion of Lati­nos in this coun­try. In Texas, for ex­am­ple, Mex­i­can Amer­i­cans faced Jim Crow-style seg­re­ga­tion; they were ex­cluded from schools, pub­lic swim­ming pools, restau­rants, movie the­aters and even cem­e­ter­ies.

Against dis­crim­i­na­tion

Per­haps one of the most pub­licly shared sto­ries of this ra­cial La­tino dis­crim­i­na­tion is the story of Felix Lon­go­ria, whose body was re­turned to his home state of Texas in 1949 af­ter he died fight­ing for his coun­try in World War II, only to be de­nied burial in his home­town be­cause the fu­neral home and cem­e­tery were for “whites only.”

In my book on Mex­i­can Amer­i­cans in Texas, nearly all of the Mex­i­can Amer­i­can re­spon­dents I in­ter­viewed who lived through the civil rights era re­called fac­ing ex­treme forms of dis­crim­i­na­tion such as at­tend­ing sep­a­rate schools and see­ing signs on restau­rants that said things such as “No Dogs, Ne­gros or Mex­i­cans.”

Advertise with us

Dis­crim­i­na­tion against Lati­nos con­tin­ues to­day, and both older and younger Mex­i­can Amer­i­cans in my study spoke of rac­ist en­coun­ters in the work­place, with po­lice, in schools. In fact, de­spite leg­is­la­tion to end school seg­re­ga­tion, to­day many school dis­tricts re­main es­sen­tially seg­re­gated for Lati­nos, who drop out of school at a higher rate than other groups.

A Har­vard Univer­sity study pub­lished in 2019 found that across mul­ti­ple lev­els — em­ploy­ment, hous­ing and health­care — Lati­nos re­ported dis­crim­i­na­tory ex­pe­ri­ences. When “La­tino” is not rec­og­nized as a ra­cial cat­e­gory, it is both an af­front to his­tory and a de­nial of these con­tin­ued ex­pe­ri­ences with rac­ism.

Be­cause it will be pos­si­ble that many Lati­nos will check only the “La­tino/​His­panic” box for the race/​eth­nic­ity ques­tion on the cen­sus, con­cerns have been raised that more spe­cific data about this com­mu­nity will be lost. In fact, re­search con­ducted by the Cen­sus Bureau shows that in­clud­ing a La­tino cat­e­gory in a “check all that ap­ply” for­mat yields more ac­cu­rate data, not less.

More ac­cu­rate data

Those who iden­tify solely as La­tino may check that box; those who iden­tify as La­tino and also as white or Black or Asian or In­dig­e­nous can make that clear as well. For ex­am­ple, Cen­sus Bureau re­search re­vealed that when white Lati­nos could iden­tify them­selves as La­tino and white in the new for­mat, those who did were ac­tu­ally white, as op­posed to many who do not iden­tify as white but have been as­signed to that race.

The num­bers of Black Lati­nos re­mained the same. This means that the new for­mat will bet­ter re­flect ac­tual ra­cial dif­fer­ences.

Advertise with us

This de­ci­sion to change how the gov­ern­ment asks about race and eth­nic­ity is the first change to fed­eral race mea­sure­ment stan­dards in 27 years. It is long over­due and will much bet­ter re­flect the ex­pe­ri­ences of Lati­nos and Mid­dle Eastern/​North African pop­u­la­tions who have fought for years to get eq­ui­ta­ble data for their com­mu­ni­ties.

Julie A. Dowling is an associate professor of sociology and Latin American and Latino studies at the University of Illinois, Chicago. She is the author of “Mexican Americans and the Question of Race,” and she served on the U.S. Census Bureau’s advisory committee on race and ethnicity from 2014 to 2020.