In every corner of the city, behemoth structures peek through construction fencing and cranes tower over neighborhoods. Floor after floor, buildings are taking shape and elbowing their way into the city’s skyline.

Almost every week another article about some future development in places we know by old names: the Civic Arena, the Giant Eagle on Penn, Wholey’s. By and large, Pittsburgh views development as a positive sign of growth and, with it, the potential for amenities: grocery stores, restaurants, and, fingers-crossed, Instagram-worthy boutiques.

But beneath these sparkling images of glass towers and balconied facades, most development projects in the city are buildings masquerading as architecture.

Density for the sake of density is not the answer. The development projects ongoing in the city are anonymous, too large for their context, and ugly. They make little attempt to connect to the area’s history or culture and often cater to a specific demographic, one that is mostly white and has financial means.

Advertise with us

That’s not to say that architects are uninvolved or that engineers haven’t made architectural calculations. In fact, that’s a problem. Scores of people work on these projects and many join in the design reviews, and still design, an essential part of architecture, goes missing.

Take 1520 Smallman, a proposed mixed-use building in the Strip District. According to the developers, the glass facade of the building is meant to reflect the city, yet the clunky massing dominates the low-rise scale of the Strip. The glass box sits up high, as cold and hard as an ice cube.

Similar problems plague East Liberty and Shadyside, where development continues to blur the boundaries between these neighborhoods. Despite criticism by Pittsburgh Planning Commissioner Becky Mingo, who likened the window treatment of the proposed redevelopment of the former Shady Hill Center to “highway motel architecture,” the development was granted approval. Site work for the project is already well underway.

Developers, by their very nature, are opportunistic. They take advantage of an area’s potential for gentrification, growth, and, most importantly, return on their investment. They probe neighborhoods and track signs of change, looking for voids in the urban fabric. The process is all about timing and it pays to be early, when land is cheapest and broader planning is not yet established.

Having worked as an architect for developer projects in New York, a big difference is that Pittsburgh seems content knowing that at least something is being done with dumpy lots. The mantra has been: What gets built is not as important as getting something built. That’s a problem. The city has carelessly allowed developers to fill voids without understanding future expansion.

Advertise with us

Other cities, where the novelty of development has faded, put developers to task. They spend money on good design and better materials to keep an advantage over their competition. Pittsburgh has yet to get over the novelty of seeing itself as the center of a development boom.

The lure for new supermarkets and additional housing are great ideas, but the final product has left much to be desired. By the time one development has proven itself, more developers swoop in and neighborhoods that once had distinct identities suddenly feel like a patchwork of bad decisions in cheap siding.

Developer projects, at their best, should be aspirational. Behind the business end of development, the project should aim to improve its area and strengthening the community. Not all buildings need to be monuments, but important sites, those that have high visibility and greater opportunities to promote social change, should rise to the occasion and do more for a larger portion of the city’s residents.

As Mayor Gainey prepares to assemble a new Art Commission, city officials and planning commissions should be more critical of and demand more of developers. The city deserves buildings with stronger design, better materials, buildings that feel grounded in our neighborhoods. It is time to stop filling voids and start creating architecture.

Gabriel Nolle, a licensed architect, is founder of GNAWorkshop in Pittsburgh and teaches courses in architecture at Chatham University and the University of Pittsburgh.