The January collapse of the Fern Hollow bridge was a high-profile infrastructure disaster. It doesn’t get much worse than a bridge falling down during rush hour with people driving across it.

And it doesn’t get much more expensive to fix. The bridge is just one of many infrastructure projects the city of Pittsburgh must pay for now and in the coming years. Some initial proposals from city council members got some things wrong. But despite public criticism — much of it well-founded — they point the way to the right long-term solution.

City Councilman Ricky Burgess, whose district partly includes the Fern Hollow bridge, first proposed a permanent Pittsburgh infrastructure trust fund, funded by a 1% tax on college tuition and medical care. After sharp backlash against the added burden on students and patients, he joined forces with Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle on a revised plan. The city would ask the city’s nonprofit organizations, including universities and hospitals, for voluntary payments in lieu of taxes  — a proposal that may get more traction.

What Mr. Burgess and Mr. Lavelle get right is the need for a local trust fund and for long-term infrastructure funding separate from the federal infrastructure bill. While the $1.2 trillion Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act provides significant funding for Pittsburgh infrastructure projects, those federal funds dry up after eight years. Most of the funds will be gone in five years — Federal funding is front-loaded.

Advertise with us

Infrastructure funding needs to last longer than that. The federal government has allocated $23.5 million in infrastructure funds to rebuild the Fern Hollow bridge. But once rebuilt, it will have to be maintained — for decades. The same is true of many other pressing local infrastructure projects.

The infrastructure bill was designed to help states upgrade critical projects and then launch their own. That raises the question that the City Council is now grappling with: Once federal infrastructure funding is exhausted, how will projects go forward, and who will pay?

User fees are one possibility. Mr. Burgess called the 1% tax in his initial proposal a “very modest” user fee. But what he describes isn’t a user fee. It’s a cost imposed on particular groups. It singled out college students and medical patients to pay for infrastructure everyone uses. The revised proposal for voluntary nonprofit funding has the same problem of singling out some groups or institutions as sources of funding.

It would make far more sense to establish true user fees — that is, fees paid by those who actually use the infrastructure. Bridge and highway tolls come immediately to mind. But given the state of much local infrastructure – badly in need of repair after decades of neglect — a simple toll system will not raise enough money.

True creativity is needed. For example, it should be possible to establish a Pittsburgh infrastructure fund via Public-Private Partnerships or PPPs. Private investors would front the immediate capital expenditure required for infrastructure upgrades across the entire bridge system.

Advertise with us

They would be repaid through 30-year bridge and highway electronic toll concessions. Drivers would pay tolls, while the PPP would capture the revenues, spend on maintaining the system, generate a profit for those who invested in the PPP, and realize a steady, long-term return. After 30 years, Pittsburgh would be able to take over the roads and bridges or decide to lease them again.

There is room for still more innovation. With funding from the proposed PPP, Pittsburgh could also upgrade its 44,000 streetlights to make them energy-efficient, using AI systems developed by U.S. technology companies. Smart streetlight systems would result in significant savings to the city, funds that could then be redeployed in other infrastructure programs. The upgrade would also decrease greenhouse gas emissions and improve road safety.

Pittsburgh is rising to the challenge of repairing, restoring and modernizing infrastructure. Mr. Burgess and his colleagues are right in their approach and are on the way to effective long-term local funding. But they must go further than they have. They must innovate, with ideas like the PPPs, to do their vision for restoring Pittsburgh’s infrastructure full justice.

Sadek Wahba, of Miami, is a senior fellow of the Development Research Institute at New York University. In 2019, Private Equity International named Mr. Wahba the Global Infrastructure Personality of the Decade.