With less than a week to go before election day, a lot of Democrats in the Buckeye State are asking a question that may haunt their party well after Nov. 8: Why did the national party say no to Ohio? They are referring to the race for U.S. Senate, where the Democratic leadership has declined to spend much money even though it couldn't have asked for a better candidate than Rep. Tim Ryan.
The 10-term member, from the White, working-class Mahoning Valley, has positioned himself as the type of independent politician that Ohioans have historically sent to Washington. He has consistently polled within the margin of error against his Republican opponent, venture-capitalist-turned-author J.D. Vance.
Maybe the party is betting it doesn't really matter how good a candidate is when the conditions for Democrats are so terrible. But is that a wise bet?
The argument for sitting out this race goes something like this: President Donald Trump won Ohio by 8 points in 2016 and in 2020. In the last presidential election, Trump won 67% of White voters without a college degree, who represent more than half of the state's electorate. In 2018, the state elected a Republican governor, Mike DeWine, who's leading his Democratic opponent by double digits. Sure, Democratic U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown has won three terms, but he's got his own brand.
The economy is a top concern for voters, with a plurality (46%) saying they are worried about inflation. President Joe Biden is drowning in Ohio, with a 37% approval rating, and off-year elections are traditionally better for the party that's not in the White House.
Sen. Chuck Schumer and national Democrats say their money is better spent in the battlegrounds of 2022 and 2024. The party needs to protect incumbents in the Senate such as Raphael Warnock of Georgia, Mark Kelly of Arizona and Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada, as well as support challengers such as Mandela Barnes in Wisconsin and John Fetterman in Pennsylvania. Notably, former President Barack Obama isn't visiting Ohio as part of his last-week-of-the-campaign blitz. (Just as notably, Trump is.)
Read More
So the case for sitting it out in Ohio is, as a psychiatrist might say, overdetermined. But Ohio Democrats can make a case for jumping in.
A candidate such as Ryan can rise above the odds, say seasoned Ohio operatives including David Pepper, former chairman of the Ohio Democratic Party. Ryan is carrying an economic populist message to the southern and eastern parts of the state — counties where Trump boosted turnout and trounced Biden.
Ryan highlights his race against Nancy Pelosi for House speaker, and boasts that he "voted with Trump on trade." He styles himself as independent and emphasizes his state citizenship more than his party membership. It's a tactic that's been used successfully in the past by Ohio senators, including not only Brown but also John Glenn and George Voinovich.
Ryan has shattered fundraising records in Ohio, bringing in almost $50 million for his campaign and vastly outpacing Vance, who has raised just under $13 million. It's led national Republicans — including Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell and billionaire Peter Thiel — to invest heavily in the race. Even as Republicans spend tens of millions of dollars in ads against Ryan, he is still polling even.
His backers note Ryan is still winning over independent voters. He's also more likable than Vance, with polls showing that more voters in Ohio view the Republican unfavorably than favorably.
Ticket-splitting could also help Ryan, with a significant number of voters expected to support the Democrat while also voting for the Republican governor. Ryan has "done everything he could humanly do" to increase turnout, says Pepper, who notes that polls show Ryan is getting 20% of DeWine voters.
Unfortunately for Ryan, at this late stage in the campaign, he may need a superhuman effort. Yes, more money would be nice, but Ohio is an expensive media market and the party would get more bang for its buck in states such as Pennsylvania and Wisconsin.
Just a few months ago, Vance was bruised from a tough primary, had spent little money and was scarce on the airwaves. McConnell decided to double down, reserving $28 million in TV and radio ads, while Democrats essentially bowed out of the race.
If Ryan loses narrowly, which is not unlikely — and if Democrats narrowly lose their Senate majority, also not unlikely — then Democrats will have to reckon with that decision. And it won't just be Democrats from Ohio who want answers.
Julianna Goldman is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. Her previous article was “Why America doesn't know how to stop school shootings.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.