Ready to repeat the baby formula crisis? This year’s disastrous government-induced infant formula shortage resulted from regulations that prevented a quick response to the shut down of a major US formula producing plant. An avoidable problem, prolonged unnecessarily. And now, unless Congress acts before the end of December, we risk a repeat of this crisis.
When the plant shut down, the market could not quickly respond, due to government protection of the market. This protectionism helped a handful of producers by keeping a captive market, like parents needing to feed their babies, captive.
When FDA approval is long and onerous, outside producers are discouraged from entering the US market. Before the shortage, the US government refused to accept formula that met the high standards of the EU, making these formulas illegal to sell in America. Our approval process kept Canadian and Mexican baby formulas, which do meet US standards, from obtaining licenses as well.
So American stores could not stock formula from Europe, Mexico or Canada. Politicians and regulators say these restrictions are needed for “safety reasons,” reasons that went out the window when parents were unable to feed their infants.
In addition to licensing issues, Congress has imposed a huge tariff (up to 17.5%) on baby formula. This makes importing it unprofitable. This, in turn, helps guarantee that families pay the maximum price for formula, unless it’s subsidized. By far the largest subsidizer of baby formula is the WIC program. WIC is responsible for half of all US infant formula purchases.
This federal program has strict rules that require states to work with only a single provider. It also makes changing providers illegal. Any glitch in supply is disastrous (and that is exactly what happened).
Read More
Finally, in May, the formula problem became so acute that even Congress had to wake up and act. Restrictions were relaxed to allow imported supplies to appear on our store shelves and in the WIC program. This helped to mitigate the shortage, but it took many weeks to take effect. By and large, consumers found the products granted emergency licenses to be safe and affordable.
Did Congress and the FDA learn their lesson? They did not.
Now, Congress and the FDA are telling import producers that these relaxed rules will be ending.
To continue to distribute infant formula in the US, every supplier must apply to the FDA by December 5th, 2022. This application must promise to comply with all existing (old) FDA regulations.
A month later, the government will decide which of the eight import suppliers will be given a chance to comply with the original rules. The tariff will remain, keeping the import of formula as unattractive as possible. Why would an importer go through the process of applying for possible FDA approval on a product that will be made unaffordable due to exorbitant import costs?
Prior to the shortage, the US produced 98% of the infant formula used in our country. An imbalance of supply like this usually occurs only with government intervention. This hurts consumers by raising prices. But in the case of a production problem, it also hurts families by making product impossible to buy.
I had hoped that when Congress discovered the formula crisis could be solved by having government get out of the way, a lesson would have been learned. Instead, our representatives have shirked their duty. Since the consumer complaints have died down, Congress has, in effect, rolled over and gone back to sleep.
It is the public who should have difficulty sleeping, because when Congress ensures that few producers can participate in a not-so-free market, a shortage can easily happen again. If and when that happens, how enthusiastic will those import suppliers be to help us out?
Millions of young families face soaring inflation and an expensive winter. They need Congress to repeal and revise the laws governing the baby formula market before this year ends. Congress must end the import tariff and revise our licensing requirements to allow the supplies that are on our store shelves today to remain there.
Liz Terwilliger, an early intervention speech pathologist living in Warren Center, Pa., is a founding member of Reform Congress. Her previous article was “Even your DNA isn't your own. The government can take it without a warrant.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.