In the PG Insight article “To fix the school system, everyone must sacrifice” (Sept. 15), Jason Spak argued that one of the purposes of magnet programs, to desegregate the schools, is now backfiring. He advocates for going back to neighborhood schools.

I’m not sure that this is the answer. Reverting to neighborhood schools would not correct the “racial gap” as the author identifies it, but present an “obvious drawback.” Although the PPS magnet program steered clear of desegregation by court order, neighborhood schools would be reflective of de facto segregation given the make up of many of Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods. In a world where interacting with others of various backgrounds is crucial, magnet programs did bring students together who may not have had the opportunity to meet, learn with and from one another — an obvious plus.

However, whether it’s in a magnet or neighborhood school, the gap that needs to be addressed is the racial achievement gap rather than the make up of the student population. All PPS magnet and traditional schools are staffed by respected teachers who bring their content expertise, their commitment to effective teaching, and their passion for ensuring successful educational outcomes for ALL students which are paramount in the quest to eliminate racial achievement disparities.

These are tough times in education but PPS teachers and administrators are tougher.

Advertise with us

Diane Carrol

Stanton Heights

The writer is a retired central office administrator in the Pittsburgh Public School system