I found Gustavo Arellano’s critique of JD Vance in Saturday’s edition (“JD Vance isn’t a real hillbilly,” July 20) interesting. The opinion piece had little to do with defining a hillbilly and everything to do with what’s wrong with Mr. Vance. It was a point-by-point litany of Vance’s lack of principles.

Then in closing, Mr. Arellano circled back with this over-arching point: Vance can’t be a genuine hillbilly because all real hillbillies are “principled” to a fault.

I grew up in Butler, Pennsylvania, but lived for a while in Middletown, Ohio, where people often referred to families that migrated from Kentucky and West Virginia as “Briars,” a slur synonymous with hillbilly. I’ll bet that term was thrown at JD many times, as he grew up in Middletown. Later, Mr. Vance lived and wrote about eloquently about the culture he came from.

Take your shots at JD Vance’s changes on policy or his policy differences from Trump. But check the identity politics at the door. An LA writer is about as qualified to identify a true hillbilly as I am to judge who in Louisiana is a “real Cajun.”

Advertise with us

John Newcaster

Palm Desert, Ca.