While I enjoyed Brandon McGinley’s column “The empire has no clothes: The debate where America bared all” (June 3), I found his central conceit ultimately to be inapt.
When Mr. McGinley says America resembles the late Roman empire, he’s likely talking about 3rd century Rome, some time after the era of the five good emperors, but not yet the pivotal 4th century when Constantine converted the empire to Christianity and moved the capital from Rome to Constantinople, even after which there was still nearly a full century until Alaric’s siege. So we’re still a ways off.
As bad as our leaders are, we still have a representative democracy with a vibrant senate and confederation of states. Rome did not. Their senate was powerless in the imperial period. Their provinces were oppressed by the palace.
Many of Rome’s 3rd century emperors were children who inherited the throne, some bought the office at auction, others took it by force and assassination. There were many civil wars, military dictatorships, public executions, and millions of slaves.
We’re moving in the wrong direction, and there are some disturbing parallels, but not enough to truly make the case. We don’t have an emperor, yet.
Clayton Deutsch
Washington, D.C.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.