Some of the many reactions to Senator Chuck Schumer’s speech (“Schumer urges new leadership in Israel, calling Netanyahu an obstacle to peace,” Mar. 14) constitute a powerful contemporary exemplar of why religious nationalism is a bad idea — something that our Framers firmly believed more than two centuries ago.

Critics of the nation of Israel are accused of anti-semitism, and the bad acts of the nation Israel fuel anti-semitism. The idea of Israel was conceived in the aftermath of World War I and eventually birthed in 1948, from a toxic mix of colonialism, western anti-semitism, and the horrors of the Holocaust.

There appears to be no way out of the long-standing cauldron of fear, hatred and violence. If there is, what is it?

Bruce Wilder

New Orleans