One can applaud Jonathan Kuttab’s calling out religious institutions — both churches and synagogues — for their “muted reactions” to the horrific suffering of the people of Gaza (“What Christians should know about Gaza,” Mar. 9).
He is right that the church’s history of persecution against Jews may be the cause of its reticence, but he misses the fact that many — including in the Jewish community here in Pittsburgh — have been both critical of Israel’s policies and supportive of the country’s right to defend itself.
Israel’s defenders point to the double standard applied to the Jewish state’s actions: condemning Israeli actions while staying silent or excusing the same behavior by other states. Sadly, Mr. Kuttab’s article exemplifies this tendency.
His criticism of Israel’s action makes no mention of Hamas’ culpability in this war — thousands of rockets rained on Israel for nearly 20 years, rejection of the very right of the country to exist — nor its construction of military facilities under hospitals and amidst the civilian population.
Most egregious is his assertion that the “events” of October 7 have been taken “out of context.” Out of context? What context would be appropriate to excuse the beheading of babies, burning of families alive, slaughter of scores of civilians, use of sexual violence on a mass scale (confirmed by the UN, not typically partial to Israel).
Minimizing such acts by placing them “in context” not only exonerates the perpetrators of such these atrocities but undermines an otherwise worthy call to conscience that should apply to all actors in this conflict.
Ronald H. Linden
Greenfield




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.