People don’t use cash anymore. According to the Federal Reserve, only 16% of in-store retail transactions in the United States in 2023 were paid in cash. The greenback death spiral is expected to continue: people over 55 account for the majority of cash transactions. To the young, paper portraits of dead presidents may as well be wampum.
Until I became a small business owner, I never worried about this. What difference does payment method make? The same amount of money comes out of my bank account, whether I’m using my card at a store or at an ATM. (In fact, sometimes ATMs with their fees are the more expensive option).
Cash was the old way, electronic debit is the new way. The results, I thought, are the same.
Not the same
In fact the results are not the same. Electronic debit methods offer the consumer supreme convenience. However, it’s not free — it’s paid for by retail business owners. Payment processing generally costs just under 3% of gross receipts for a business.
I run a bookstore in Steubenville, Ohio. Books are a fun business, but not very profitable. Bookstores across the country, big or small, generally run an annual profit between 2 and 10% of gross sales. Paying 3% for card processing is a huge chunk out of our profits – between 30% and 150% of a bookshop’s typical margin.
The money doesn’t just vanish: it goes overwhelmingly to large financial institutions, the sort of companies that are headquartered in big cities and traded on stock exchanges. It’s Wall Street taking a cut. If you’re in a rich town, it may not make much difference.
Read More
But it’s a different story here in Steubenville. The square mile that comprises our downtown has a per capita income of about $6000 a year. A recent survey commissioned by the city determined that 80% of the buildings in the central business district were “deteriorated” or “dilapidated.”
Here every dollar counts, and the loss from payment processing is profound. The average business here is always trying to catch up on the city’s deferred maintenance — trying to replace a boiler or rip up old carpets or restore a tin ceiling or renovate an abandoned second floor.
The $5,000 I pay in credit card fees every year hurts. But larger businesses might be paying $50,000 a year. That’s a lost renovation project, a lost expansion, a lost product line, a lost employee. These losses compound year after year.
Changing behavior
It makes a difference. Every year, our Main Streets lose 3% of their vitality, and send it off to Wall Street. It’s visible in every little town in America that doesn’t have access to Wall Street money.
This is why you increasingly see card fees at retail businesses. Main Street was already having trouble fighting against “the death of retail” in America.
Now we have to give big finance a cut, and since we don’t stand to win a fight against the fat cats, the main recourse is to put the cost onto the consumer. The hope, however, is not that customers will pay these fees themselves, but that they will change their behavior and use cash.
I know I have changed. Like most people I had slowly gotten out of the habit of using cash. Now I make sure to take $200 out at a time from an ATM. At big corporate stores, it probably doesn’t make much difference: I don’t feel bad about using my card at Walmart. But any time I visit a mom-and-pop store, I use cash.
There are other advantages of hard currency, not least the greater individual freedom. I’ve had my debit card frozen while on vacation, because there have been charges at gas stations in multiple states on the same day. When I called my card company complaining, the representative told me I should talk to my bank before going on any trip. No thank you.
Similarly we had our card processing cut off one day in the middle of our business day — with no reason given for the cutoff. There’s an off switch between us and the global financial system, and someone else has their finger on it.
Dollars are enough
American hippies fixated on localism used to fantasize about local currencies that could only be used in a single town, to keep local dollars local. Now it is turning out that American dollars are local enough — if we use them.
The cards are stacked against local businesses. Dollars aren’t. But you have to have them in your wallet to make a difference. Every time you spend money, you can choose to feed the fat cats — or not. What’s in your wallet?
John Byron Kuhner runs Bookmarx Books in Steubenville, Ohio. His previous article was “Steubenville is reviving its downtown with statues.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.