Now that election season is over, and Congress is back in session, thousands of Pennsylvania small businesses are counting on Congress to do what they promised on the campaign trail — cutting government spending, reducing onerous regulations, and lowering taxes.
The U.S. Tax Code is a case study in typical Washington, D.C. operations, with special carve-outs for big corporations and other special interests always taking priority in the discussions. The needs of small businesses are often lost in the debate, even though they employ tens of millions of Americans — nearly 45% of Pennsylvanians are employed by one.
The key
Tax fairness is key in helping small businesses invest with confidence and grow. Even within specific industries, however, there can be wide disparities in tax treatment. One glaring example is in the service industry, where certain businesses get a generous tax break while others do without.
In 1993, Congress approved a tax provision granting restaurants and bars a dollar-for-dollar reimbursement for FICA taxes paid on workers' tips above the minimum wage. While I certainly support this provision — restaurants should not have to pay tax on income from which they derive no benefit — it always puzzled me why its application was so narrow.
Other small businesses in the service industry, like salons, spas, and barbershops, are the backbone of many Pennsylvania communities. They are where generations of neighbors meet, socialize, share problems, and seek advice.
And most of their employees receive the majority of their compensation from tips.
Unfair taxes
However, these businesses don’t receive the same tax treatment as restaurants and must pay full freight for their employee’s tip wages. That is a shame because they are vital to not only the social fabric of the Commonwealth but also its economy.
This industry provides employment opportunities for more than 32,000 Pennsylvanians. This isn’t surprising considering Pennsylvania is in the top five for states with the highest employment levels of hairstylists, hairdressers, and cosmetologists.
With 60% of these small businesses owned by women and 25% by minorities, the industry is a leader in providing entrepreneurial opportunities to a diverse group of Pennsylvanians. Making it easier for these businesses to survive, grow, expand, and thrive will allow them to create more jobs, stimulating economic growth in their communities.
Spas, salons, and barbershops bore much of the economic hardship that resulted from the COVID-19 pandemic. Most were forced to shut down and lay off their workers — you can’t get a haircut or your nails done remotely — and many are still struggling with a massive backlog of bills while rebuilding their pre-2020 clientele. They deserve relief.
Tax relief
Fortunately, help might be on the way. Pennsylvania Reps. Lloyd Smucker and Mike Kelly have cosponsored the Small Business Tax Fairness and Compliance Simplification Act, which would apply the FICA tax rebate to the personal grooming industry.
Both serve on the House Ways and Means Committee — the committee responsible for creating federal tax policy — which means that there is a great chance of tax fairness finally coming for Pennsylvania’s service workers.
While small businesses are the lifeblood of Pennsylvania’s and America’s economy, the truth is salons and barbershops are not just small businesses. They are community hubs, cultural pillars and lifelines for many of our neighborhoods, especially those in underserved areas. This bill would offer them a crucial lifeline, and Congress should pass it immediately.
Rick Santorum represented Pennsylvania in the Senate from 1995 to 2007. His previous article was “Kamala Harris' idea of government will not make housing cheaper.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.