Western thought has imagined that reason is cool, rational and sophisticated, emotions primitive, impulsive and likely to lead you astray. A wise person uses reason to override and control the primitive passions.
Modern neuroscience has delivered a body blow to this way of thinking. Now we understand that emotions are often wise. Most of the time they guide reason and make us more rational.
So what are some of the things modern neuroscience has taught us?
Your body knows
In his classic book “Descartes’ Error” Anthony Damasio had studied patients who had trouble processing emotions. They weren’t supersmart Mr. Spocks. They were unable to make decisions and their lives spiraled.
He demonstrated that emotions deftly assign value to things. Without knowing what’s important, or what’s good or bad, the brain just spins its wheels. Emotions and reason are one system integral to good decision-making.
Since then, neuroscientists have jumped into the study of emotions with both feet. We have a better understanding of how emotions form and what they do for us. To oversimplify a bit, below conscious awareness, your body is constantly reacting to the events around you: heart speeding or slowing, breaths getting shorter or longer, your metabolism purring or groaning.
Many of these reactions happen in the enteric nervous system in the gastrointestinal tract, which is sometimes called “the second brain.” There are upward of several hundred million neurons in that system; 95% of the neurotransmitter serotonin is there.
Every second of every day, your brain is monitoring the signals sent up from your body and rushing to assign a meaning to them. Is this set of bodily responses nervousness? Anxiety? No! This is terror!
The body kicks into gear and then the mind constructs an emotional experience. It feels like we get scared and start running from the bear. But as psychologist William James brilliantly intuited over a century ago, it’s more accurate to say we start running from the bear and then we get scared.
Emotions put us in the right mind-state so that we can effectively think about the situation we’re in the middle of. They slant the mind in one direction or another depending on circumstances.
Indignation helps us focus on injustice. Awe motivates us to feel small in the presence of grandeur and to be good to others. Euphoria put us in a risk-taking frame of mind. Happiness makes people more creative, more flexible in their thinking. Disgust primes us to reject immoral behavior.
Fear helps amplify our senses and focus attention. Anxiety puts us in a pessimistic state of mind, less likely to take chances. Sadness improves memory, helps us make more accurate judgments, makes us clearer communicators and more attentive to fairness.
Neuroscientist John Coates knows that sometimes our emotions get things wrong. Before he was a neuroscientist, he was a Wall Street trader. In his brilliant 2012 book, “The Hour Between Dog and Wolf,” he describes how bull markets could change traders’ emotional mindsets.
“As a bull market starts to validate investors’ beliefs,” he writes, “the profits they make translate into a lot more than mere greed: they bring on powerful feelings of euphoria and omnipotence. ... Assessment of risk is replaced by judgments of certainty — they just know what is going to happen.”
Testosterone was flowing. Dopamine came in torrents. This is the kind of mindset that produces bubbles and the odd global financial crisis. Euphoria goeth before the fall.
How can traders do their jobs without making the global financial system go kablooey? The answer isn’t to repress emotions. What they need is emotional self-awareness. Research shows that effective traders are hypersensitive to physical changes — to, say, variations in their heartbeats. In other words, they are exceptionally good at emotional appraisal: What is my body telling me and is it helpful or overwrought?
Emotional athleticism
My core point here is that you need to be a great emotional athlete in order to make the great decisions in life. You need to be ardent enough to feel and astute enough to understand your feelings. Life is not a series of calculus problems. Life is about movement — moving through different terrains and circumstances.
Emotions guide the navigation system. As Leonard Mlodinow writes in “Emotional,” “While IQ scores may correlate to cognitive abilities, control over and knowledge of one’s emotional state is what is most important for professional and personal success.”
When people get fired, it’s rarely because they lack technical abilities; it’s almost always because they’re uncoachable, they have anger issues or they’re bad teammates. In other words, they lack emotional skills, a fact often undetected in the hiring process.
We’ve always known that emotion is central to the art of human connection. Now we understand that emotion is central to being an effective rational person in the world.
And yet most of us are emotionally inarticulate. If you are going to hire, marry, befriend, manage or coach people, shouldn’t you know their core affect, the emotional base line they carry through life? Shouldn’t you know their emotional profile, the distinctive way they construct emotions in diverse circumstances?
David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article first appeared.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.