I write to express my thoughts on the recent Revitalization Initiative announced by the Allegheny Conference. My company, Hullett Properties, has recently finished the adaptive reuse project of the Triangle Building at 701 Smithfield St. Downtown.

This account is from the viewpoint of a developer engaged in the active conversion of historic downtown buildings in Pittsburgh, with insight into City permitting procedures and construction expenses, and firsthand knowledge of investing in and securing private and public funding sources for real estate development projects focused on historic conversion and adaptive reuse.

I deeply appreciate the effort to transform Downtown Pittsburgh. However, I urge those involved to prioritize one crucial goal above all others: repurposing old, functionally obsolete office buildings into new residential accommodations. Pittsburgh’s historic buildings are ripe for conversion from an engineering and architectural standpoint, given floor plate dimensions of the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Leaving buildings empty contributes to a downward spiral of declining property values and the corollary of a declining tax base and increasing antisocial behavior. Vacant buildings often lead to low-quality retail out of landlord desperation, further deteriorating the streetscape.

Advertise with us

Compelling logic

The logic for repurposing office buildings into residences is compelling.

First, with a 95% residential occupancy rate, it’s clear that people already want to live downtown in its current state, whatever complaints there are of its present conditions. This statistic underscores a strong demand for downtown living.

Second, from a cultural perspective, repurposing these buildings maintains our connection to the past, respects our heritage, and retains the aesthetic beauty of building practices of the bygone era where customized masonry was ubiquitous. This is not only good for the spirit but also for preserving the unique character of our city.

Third, there is a substantial pool of private investment ready to fund 80% to 85% of redevelopment costs for these historic buildings if they can secure the remaining 15% to 20% in public or private supported subsidy investments, like low-interest financing.

This claim is not speculative; it’s based on my direct conversations with investors and developers, and my own work on obtaining financing for converting a soon-to-be-vacant office building in the middle of Penn Avenue’s cultural district. This project, like many others, hinges on securing that crucial subsidy investment to proceed.

Advertise with us

We must also consider policy improvements that could boost conversion development and require no financial outlay. For example, California is considering Assembly Bill 835, which would reduce the requirement for two stairways to one in multifamily housing. This would be a seismic innovation in code that would dramatically lower construction costs, especially for historic buildings.

Policy leaders with little experience in development would understandably not appreciate this game-changing nuance. This is just one example of how engaging developers early in the process can yield practical insights for more efficient policy-making — something that was regrettably overlooked in the Allegheny Conference’s planning.

City councilman Bobby Wilson’s engaged approach with the real estate development industry in drafting the recent Enhanced LERTA amendment stands in contrast. Without this crucial amendment, the city would have lost its most important proposed development downtown: the redevelopment of the Gulf Tower.

This project is the single most transformative current real estate undertaking in Downtown and as I understand is now set to break ground subject to approval from a state subsidy program.

A complicated equation

From tax abatements, to low-interest loans, historic tax credits and code changes — the reality is that the conversion equation is a complicated one and requires developers at the table from beginning to end who are actively converting such buildings. No one is against the proposed new parks that will bring more vibrancy and amenities to Downtown.

Advertise with us

I personally frequent the High Line whenever in Manhattan. But even when you look at how that game-changing, creative public space was created it followed massive governmental incentives to incent Downtown living, largely through residential conversions, post 9/​11.

Now is the time to delve into the details as to what developers truly need to move these difficult and risky projects into construction. We have a target of converting 1,000 residential units from adaptive reuse of architecturally significant historic office buildings downtown.

If we adhere to the 10% affordability mandate of the LERTA property tax abatement program, developers would need a subordinate loan fund lending at $100,000 per building unit. A building that produced 50 units would need a $5,000,000 subsidy. To accomplish our 1,000 unit goal we would need $100,000,000.

This fund would enable the conversion of 25 identified buildings deemed suitable for this purpose, while also providing retail warm shell spaces ready for retail tenant build-outs. To achieve this, the fund would ideally offer loans at an interest rate as close to 0% as possible, with a term matching the current LERTA program, which is 10 years, and sit behind the first security position of a construction loan lender.

If used in combination with a replenished URA Pittsburgh Downtown Conversion Plan fund, this would lead to a greater proportion of low income or affordable units. Additionally, it would be very helpful if the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania increased the fund cap and per project cap of the state historic tax credit called the Historic Preservation Tax Credit to at least be in in with neighboring states of New Jersey and Ohio.

Advertise with us

I would also suggest the Commonwealth broaden the eligibility of its new PA Sites program to include historic multifamily conversions. This would accomplish a goal of introducing 1,000 new residential units and trigger new favored retail tenancies in these buildings.

Prioritize housing

Let’s not abandon the Allegheny Conference’s plan, but prioritize. It is just not what is the optimal use of government funding today in Pittsburgh. The immediate focus must be on creating safe, clean and affordable modern housing downtown.

This approach will maximize the impact of limited resources, attract massive private investment, spark new desirable retail offerings and preserve our architectural heritage. And once we get moving on job-creating conversions — then let’s prioritize this Allegheny Conference plan.

Let’s heed the wisdom of prioritization and make the most significant difference where it is currently needed most.

Brett Walsh is one of the two principals of Pittsburgh-based developer Hullett Properties.