Nothing thus far in Pittsburgh’s current age of mediocrity has demonstrated the city’s (and region’s) lack of leadership more clearly than the embarrassing “revitalization initiative” for Downtown unveiled Wednesday by the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, Allegheny County and the City of Pittsburgh.
While it’s been amateur hour on Grant Street for some time now, this episode demonstrates that Pittsburgh’s unelected leadership is failing to fill the gaps in competency and vision left by its elected leadership.
Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership CEO Jeremy Waldrup, whose organization has done yeoman’s work to stabilize the Golden Triangle, said it best in his tepid attempt to promote the vision: “We don’t have a proposed plan yet, except that we want to make it better.”
Great. We’re more than four years past the onset of the COVID pandemic; two and a half years into the mayoralty of Ed Gainey; and several months into the county administration of Sara Innamorato. The threat of cascading fiscal crises due to the collapse of Downtown property values has been clear for years. Comparable cities have proved that post-pandemic urban-core recovery is possible, and provided blueprints for success.
But in Pittsburgh, in June 2024, “we don’t have a proposed plan yet.”
Blocked out
The power of the Allegheny Conference — that storied consortium of regional business leaders — has always been as the great convener. It collected stakeholders across parties and sectors to hammer out regional strategic initiatives. It forced politicians to accept bitter economic realities they couldn’t, or didn’t want to, face on their own.
Now, the Conference acquiesces as politicians exclude disfavored voices, and helps them paper over reality.
Wednesday’s joint press release boasts of having “40+ downtown-focused organizations” on board with the “vision plan.” It’s unclear who these organizations are, but it is clear there was no meaningful dialogue with property developers. These are the people who understand what’s needed to clear the financial and regulatory hurdles to renewed vibrancy, yet they were presented with a fait accompli that addressed none of the immediate practical impediments to Downtown’s success. And so nothing will change.
This isn’t about hurt feelings: It’s about the reality that you can’t plan for the future of Downtown without the people who own land and build projects Downtown. You don’t have to like them to realize you need them.
We’ve come to expect this from the Gainey administration. But for the Allegheny Conference to ratify this approach to leadership is just dispiriting. Are there any real leaders left in Pittsburgh?
Only aspirations
There had been buzz around the city leading up to Wednesday’s announcement. Talk of a real attempt at public-private collaboration. A sense that the promise of the NFL draft in 2026 might trigger a pragmatic, all-hands approach to the structural economic challenges facing the Golden Triangle.
Instead, we got three disconnected and “aspirational” (Conference CEO Stefani Pashman’s word) urban design concepts — with no roadmap to completion, no funding plan, no policy initiatives, no economic strategy, no realistic timelines. Just some very handsome watercolor renderings from a very expensive consultant.
There’s nothing wrong with the ideas themselves — except that they’re all blazingly obvious.
Of course Point State Park and its environs could use more structure. But regarding Liberty Avenue, this proposal (pickleball courts in the median?) is much less ambitious than the full pedestrianization proposed by Bill Peduto — and scrapped by Mr. Gainey.
Of course Market Square should have been fully pedestrian from the beginning. But the few cars that venture onto the Belgian block aren’t what’s holding back the square. That would be regular brawls among teenagers and an economic environment that has killed off many of its restaurants.
And of course the Eighth Avenue corridor is a drain on the vitality of the Cultural District. I was just at the Goodyear shop getting a company car serviced, and — no offense to the fine people who run the place — we all know that slab of concrete is a pimple on the face of Downtown.
Unserious leadership
Anyone with a hint of imagination could identify these as areas for improvement — but they’re also in parts of Downtown that are already doing pretty well. What about Smithfield, Pittsburgh’s historic main street, which is dying? What about the Boulevard of the Allies, an asphalt gash through the heart of the Golden Triangle?
And what about the actual issue: the structural economic problems for downtown development in the post-pandemic economy? The press release claims that “short-term stabilization” has already successfully occurred Downtown. That’s mayoral campaign propaganda — under the banner of the Allegheny Conference — not a serious reckoning with reality.
Serious cities with serious leaders have tackled reality head-on. In Cincinnati, there are hundreds of new residences in the urban core, and a major company is moving its headquarters from the suburbs to downtown. Mayor Aftab Pureval, who took office in 2022, saw the threat to his city’s prosperity from a withering downtown and formed a commission including as many public and private interests as possible.
In other words, he created what the Allegheny Conference is supposed to be. What it no longer is.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.