Last Wednesday’s joint announcement of a “long-term strategic redevelopment and investment strategy” for Downtown reflected a deeply troubling ignorance among the region’s elected and unelected leaders of what the Golden Triangle — and therefore Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania as a whole — needs to thrive.

The coalition, featuring the Allegheny Conference on Community Development alongside Allegheny County and the City of Pittsburgh, failed to meaningfully engage key stakeholders, including land owners and building developers. It therefore failed to address the fundamental challenges of post-pandemic economics that face Downtown.

The three urban design proposals the consortium settled on, after apparently over a year of work with a top New York-based consultant, are lovely — but they are, in the words of Allegheny Conference CEO Stefani Pashman, “aspirational.”

Aspirations do not meet the city’s actual needs. Developers are sitting on hundreds of millions of dollars of potential Downtown projects, which would keep currently failing buildings on the tax rolls and bring hundreds of permanent residents to the Golden Triangle. But with the rising costs of materials and labor, sky-high interest rates and more conservative lending from banks, the finances for these projects don’t work.

Advertise with us

Developers’ pleas have thus far fallen on deaf ears, with the exception of the enhanced tax abatements successfully pushed by City Councilman Bobby Wilson. Pittsburgh’s leaders don’t have to give the developers everything they want — in fact, they shouldn’t — but they do need to listen, and to understand that Downtown will never be truly revitalized without them.

Historic Downtown

Pittsburgh’s Downtown built environment is tailor-made for office-to-residential conversions. With dozens of mid- and high-rise buildings from the golden age of American commercial architecture, the city is very well-positioned to benefit from the trend toward preserving these gems as apartments and condominiums, feeding the desire for dense urban living. The current Downtown occupancy rate of 95% strongly suggests the market is not yet saturated.

Especially along the Penn and Liberty corridors, Pittsburgh is rich with conversion options. Older (pre-HVAC) buildings with small floorplates are ideal for preservation, because there’s less infrastructure to move around. However, these conversions — especially in larger buildings, like the Gulf Tower — are still extremely expensive, often more expensive than tearing down the old building and building a new one, inevitably in a blander, more modern style.

That means policies that encourage conversions don’t just get projects moving. They preserve Pittsburgh’s history.

Harrisburg helping hand

To that end, a top priority for state lawmakers should be expanding Pennsylvania’s historic preservation tax credits, which reward developers for keeping intact the structures that make Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

The credits available statewide in a single fiscal year are capped at only $5 million. That’s the lowest in the region: Compare to tiny Delaware’s $8 million, or Ohio’s $120 million. New York and West Virginia have no caps at all. Expanding these tax credits would take a very small bite out of the commonwealth’s enormous reserves, and generate many times their worth in tax revenue — not to mention construction jobs.

The state’s Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance program, which abates the increase in taxes due to property development for a maximum of 10 years, also lags peer states. Cincinnati and Cleveland, with comparable downtown building stocks, offer 15-year abatements, and have seen hundreds of new units come on-line. Pittsburgh’s developers are looking for 20 years, but that’s not necessary. Fifteen should suffice.

Looking for leaders

These state policy efforts can and should be bipartisan. It was particularly disappointing to see the Allegheny Conference, meant to be a nonpartisan convener, announce its “vision plan” with only County Executive Sara Innamorato and Mayor Ed Gainey — no state legislators, and no Republicans.

The Conference also missed an opportunity to expand an initiative of its own: the Strategic Investment Fund. The current SIF is largely spoken for, but an expansion of, say, $40 million to $50 million could fill funding gaps for several Downtown development projects.

The SIF has a regional focus, though a parallel version could be created focusing on Downtown focus. It is traditionally funded by the private sector, but a new Downtown SIF could be seeded by state funds that are matched by foundation and corporate partners.

Advertise with us

Disbursements from the fund would be in the form of low-interest subordinated (or mezzanine) loans — not grants. That means  the fund would get paid back only after other debt, such as bank debt, has been paid off. It’s a higher risk form of lending than banks can take on, but it’s for a public purpose. And as the loans are paid off — which they will be most of the time — the fund will recoup its value.

Beyond “aspirations”

Lastly, the coalition should have taken a page from Gov. Josh Shapiro’s book and promised permitting reform. Like most cities, permitting in Pittsburgh is a bureaucratic and political nightmare — as evidenced by the unconscionable and possibly illegal delays the city forced Walnut Capital to endure to expand the wildly successful Bakery Square development in Larimer.

Permitting delays can scuttle developments as costs rise, especially in an inflationary environment — and discourage developers from even giving Downtown a chance. Mr. Shapiro is developing a schedule of strict permitting deadlines that become automatic approvals if government officials miss them. Any legitimate Downtown plan would include the same — say, 60 days for most applications.

These specific, practical policy initiatives are what the Allegheny Conference and regional governments should have announced last Wednesday. That all they could muster were “aspirations” and pretty pictures suggests that the region’s leaders don’t actually know — or even care to find out — what Pittsburgh needs to thrive again.