One of my greatest joys as a congregational rabbi is being with families as they celebrate Bar/t Mitzvah — the Jewish coming of age ceremony. Each week on Shabbat, I sit on the bima and look out into the congregation where I see the faces of family and friends, young and old. The best part of the entire celebration is the expression on the parents’ faces as they watch their child chant from sacred scripture for the very first time. It’s a moment of pride, transformation and transmission of Judaism.
But one week, in late fall of 2018, was different. I arrived at my chair on the bima as always, ready for joy and family and prayer. But on that particular week, the family did not gush with happiness and pride. Instead, they sat there in the congregation, and they all cried. In fact, they sobbed.
I’ve witnessed a good deal of sadness in my professional life — death, illness, suffering. But this was the first moment I had ever seen people embody what it means to weep. The adults, the children — they all looked broken. I was shocked. Why would there be such sorrow on a day of celebration?
After the service, I found out why. The family was mourning the murder of the matriarch of their family, who had been killed in the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting only a few weeks before. That moment, when I witnessed their weeping, will never leave me.
Learning together
Nearly five years later, the legal aspect of this horror has come to a close, or at least a long pause, but the pastoral process of healing continues. Now that the sentence has been delivered, whether we are Jewish or not, the question becomes: What do we do now? What comes next? How can we move forward?
Read More
A number of my Christian clergy colleagues have inquired about forgiveness. Could the Jewish community as a whole ever forgive the gunman for such an act of murder? In truth, I flinch a bit when asked this question: It just doesn’t match with Jewish ideas about forgiveness.
But my colleagues do not ask this question to diminish or deny the guilt and evil of the perpetrator. Nor do they ask me about forgiveness to deny Jews the right to experience our profound anger. Rather, they ask this question out of a particular Christian, religious perspective of how to move forward.
After all, the victims of the families in Charleston after the horrific shooting at a historically African American church famously forgave the gunman in public. That was the religious paradigm within which those particular survivors felt it was best to move forward.
But for the Jewish people, forgiveness is not necessarily the proper religious framework for responding to such trauma. Instead, we can look to our mourning process to understand what comes next — and non-Jewish people might do to do continue to help us fight antisemitism.
Mourning together
In Judaism, when a loved one dies, our mourning process begins with seven days of intense grief, a period known as shiva. During this week, mourners stay inside their home, where visitors treat them with love and compassion. The community tends to them, caring for both their physical and spiritual needs.
A daily prayer service is held, so that the mourners may recite the proper prayers. Friends, family, and community members visit and bring some food for the mourners. This period of intense grieving gives the mourners a chance to withdraw from the world and begin to process their loss.
And then, when those seven days come to an end, the mourners get up and do something: They leave their house and go on a walk outside. The walk is often accompanied by friends and family as a way to symbolize the start of re-entry into the world. We are still in great pain, but we are also moving forward, and we are not alone.
As we, the Jewish people, move on from this most intense period of mourning, the question is: Will the rest of the country, largely made up of non-Jews, consider walking with us as we continue to explore how to fight antisemitism?
Walking together
What is happening in our country today feels familiar in many ways. We recognize the classical canards of antisemitism, such as accusations that we are responsible for a secret plot to dominate the world or overthrow the government. We have seen hate from neo-nazis and their white supremacist supporters before.
But the unprecedented spike in antisemitism feels new at the same time. Its proliferation through social media; the casual, but continuing attacks from public figures; and the lack of generally shared lived experience with pervasive antisemitism: These feel unfamiliar and scary. So we, the Jewish people, don’t know everything about how to stop this hate or even process what happened. Rather, we are trying to move forward and we need the support of non-Jews to do so.
Jews make up less than 0.2% of the global population and around 2% of the American population. There are only about fifteen million Jews left in the entire world, around eight million of whom live in the United States. The Jews are a statistical anomaly, a rounding error, a tiny minority in a country of minorities. And yet we are the victims of nearly 60% of religiously motivated hate crimes here. We need the broader world to walk with us as we figure out how to move ahead.
Walking with the Jewish community as we fight this hate means validating our concerns. If we feel we need additional security, help us find a way to do it. If we are concerned about political rhetoric or school yard conversations, listen to our disquietude.
And don’t worry: It’s ok, and even encouraging, to be curious about us. Ask us questions about what it means to be Jewish. Ask us about our immigration stories or about Jewish holidays. Find a way to engage with the Jewish community. Be our partners as we reject this pernicious hate. And we, in turn, will be partners with you, building a sense of allyship and communal understanding.
Nothing can undo the heinous violence of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting. But we have no choice but to try and move forward together — one step at a time.
Diana Fersko is the author of “We Need to Talk About Antisemitism” and the Senior Rabbi of The Village Temple in New York City.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.