Collective punishment is a fitting word to describe what is happening in the Middle East right now. Those attending a concert in Israel or the families eking out a modest living from the hard soil of a kibbutz are unjustly held responsible for the.injustices inflicted upon Palestinians and are slaughtered.
It’s the same story in Gaza. Everyday people are dying because of the hideous convictions of Hamas.
It’s the innocent who pay the price for violent aggression. Ukraine is another example.
Infants, children, women and ordinary men are not culpable for the inhumane acts of others. But all of them are paying the price for decisions made by those far above any ability of ordinary folks to change the circumstances. This always seems to be the case: The blameless pay the price for what the guilty have done and are doing right now.
In a way, it’s no different in our own country. Americans who are ethnic Palestinians already are feeling the hammer of retribution for what a despicable group, with the same ethnic background, have perpetuated. American Jews are being targeted for violent harm because of conditions in which they had no part.
Collective retribution? You bet your life it is.
Read More
Josep Borrell Fontelles, the top E.U. diplomat, said, “Not all the Palestinian people are terrorists. So a collective punishment against all Palestinians will be unfair and unproductive and will be against our interest and against the interest of the peace.” The same is true of Hamas’s collective attack on all Israelis.
We really have lost a vital sense of our common humanity when we group people together and target them with venomous hatred. It only takes a perverse few to poison the image of everyone else in their genetic, religious and cultural identity.
When we do that, we are no better than those we righteously condemn. When entire categories of people are reduced to labels, there is little room to admit significant differences.
Weapons and violence can’t erase trauma. Fear-based aggression is ineffective. It’s no wonder that there is an acute sense of despair among Israelis and Palestinians, as many are convinced that conflict resolution is impossible.
This certainly is true among the young. I imagine they feel caught between the forces determined to be influential, no matter what it might cost. And they are the ones being turned into grist.
The question of self-worth is a front of mind concern, as is the prospect of positive tangible expectations. All that they have known in life has failed to create a harmonious present. Grievances still rule the day. Hearts are cracked open to melancholy and depression. The unanswered question is, “Why?”
The abhorrent acts of Hamas cannot be condoned. There is no justification for the murders, kidnappings, rape, torture or destruction. So there must be complete agreement, worldwide, with Defense Secretary General Lloyd Austin who said, “This is no time for false equivocations.” Hamas is a terrorist movement and must be stopped.
But also believe that an essential commitment is required for a deeper empathy and understanding of the suffering of others. None is safe from harm and are vulnerable when we pigeon hole others into categories rather acknowledging them as members of our human family.
Despair is punishing and brutal. Certainly the despair of Gazans and Israelis is real since they truly are victims of collective punishment. And it’s no help when some will suggest that everything will eventually work out. That is toxic positivity.
It’s imperative to face the reality of evil, confront and overcome imperious and violent behavior, and stop physically and emotionally isolating ourselves from those who differ from us. The only constructive long term answer is to focus on our common wellbeing.
Roy Lloyd is the president of the board of the International Forgiveness Institute.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.