Col­lec­tive pun­ish­ment is a fit­ting word to de­scribe what is hap­pen­ing in the Mid­dle East right now. Those at­tend­ing a con­cert in Is­rael or the fam­i­lies ek­ing out a mod­est liv­ing from the hard soil of a kib­butz are un­justly held re­spon­si­ble for the.in­justices in­flicted upon Pal­es­tin­ians and are slaugh­tered.

It’s the same story in Gaza. Ev­ery­day peo­ple are dy­ing be­cause of the hid­eous con­vic­tions of Ha­mas.

It’s the in­no­cent who pay the price for vi­o­lent ag­gres­sion. Ukraine is an­other ex­am­ple.

In­fants, chil­dren, women and or­di­nary men are not cul­pa­ble for the in­hu­mane acts of oth­ers. But all of them are pay­ing the price for de­ci­sions made by those far above any abil­ity of or­di­nary folks to change the cir­cum­stances. This al­ways seems to be the case: The blame­less pay the price for what the guilty have done and are do­ing right now.

Advertise with us

In a way, it’s no dif­fer­ent in our own coun­try. Amer­i­cans who are eth­nic Pal­es­tin­ians al­ready are feel­ing the ham­mer of ret­ri­bu­tion for what a de­spi­ca­ble group, with the same eth­nic back­ground, have per­pet­u­ated. Amer­i­can Jews are be­ing tar­geted for vi­o­lent harm be­cause of con­di­tions in which they had no part.

Col­lec­tive ret­ri­bu­tion? You bet your life it is.

Josep Bor­rell Fon­telles, the top E.U. dip­lo­mat, said, “Not all the Pal­es­tin­ian peo­ple are ter­ror­ists. So a col­lec­tive pun­ish­ment against all Pal­es­tin­ians will be un­fair and un­pro­duc­tive and will be against our in­ter­est and against the in­ter­est of the peace.” The same is true of Hamas’s collective attack on all Israelis.

We re­ally have lost a vi­tal sense of our com­mon hu­man­ity when we group peo­ple to­gether and tar­get them with ven­om­ous ha­tred. It only takes a per­verse few to poi­son the im­age of ev­ery­one else in their ge­netic, re­li­gious and cul­tural iden­tity.

When we do that, we are no bet­ter than those we righ­teously con­demn. When en­tire cat­e­go­ries of peo­ple are re­duced to la­bels, there is lit­tle room to ad­mit sig­nifi­cant dif­fer­ences.

Advertise with us

Weapons and vi­o­lence can’t erase trauma. Fear-based ag­gres­sion is in­ef­fec­tive. It’s no won­der that there is an acute sense of de­spair among Is­rae­lis and Pal­es­tin­ians, as many are convinced that con­flict res­o­lu­tion is im­pos­sible.

This cer­tainly is true among the young. I imag­ine they feel caught be­tween the forces de­ter­mined to be in­flu­en­tial, no mat­ter what it might cost. And they are the ones be­ing turned into grist.

The ques­tion of self-worth is a front of mind con­cern, as is the pros­pect of pos­i­tive tan­gi­ble ex­pec­ta­tions. All that they have known in life has failed to cre­ate a har­mo­ni­ous pres­ent. Griev­ances still rule the day. Hearts are cracked open to mel­an­choly and de­pres­sion. The un­an­swered ques­tion is, “Why?”

The ab­hor­rent acts of Ha­mas can­not be con­doned. There is no jus­ti­fi­ca­tion for the mur­ders, kid­nap­pings, rape, tor­ture or de­struc­tion. So there must be com­plete agree­ment, world­wide, with De­fense Sec­re­tary Gen­eral Lloyd Austin who said, “This is no time for false equiv­o­ca­tions.” Ha­mas is a ter­ror­ist move­ment and must be stopped.

But also be­lieve that an es­sen­tial com­mit­ment is re­quired for a deeper em­pa­thy and un­der­stand­ing of the suf­fer­ing of oth­ers. None is safe from harm and are vul­ner­a­ble when we pi­geon hole oth­ers into cat­e­go­ries rather ac­knowl­edg­ing them as mem­bers of our hu­man fam­ily.

Advertise with us

De­spair is pun­ish­ing and bru­tal. Cer­tainly the de­spair of Gazans and Is­rae­lis is real since they truly are vic­tims of col­lec­tive pun­ish­ment. And it’s no help when some will sug­gest that ev­ery­thing will even­tu­ally work out. That is toxic pos­i­tiv­ity.

It’s im­per­a­tive to face the re­al­ity of evil, con­front and over­come im­pe­ri­ous and vi­o­lent be­hav­ior, and stop phys­i­cally and emo­tion­ally iso­lat­ing our­selves from those who dif­fer from us. The only con­struc­tive long term an­swer is to fo­cus on our com­mon well­be­ing.

Roy Lloyd is the president of the board of the International Forgiveness Institute.