Are America’s best days ahead of her or behind her? Former U.S. Senate candidate Dave McCormick poses that not as a question but as a challenge in his new book, Superpower In Peril, and then answers with a compelling sketch of a new and distinctly 21st-century conservatism. In so doing, Mr. McCormick has established himself as one of the most interesting voices and personalities in the modern American Right.
For Republicans like me, Mr. McCormick is the one that got away in the midterm elections. Torpedoed by a late endorsement of primary opponent Mehmet Oz by Donald Trump, Mr. McCormick may well have fared better against now-Sen. John Fetterman and kept Democrats from full control of that chamber.
Still, while some Republicans who have found themselves at odds with former President Trump have become embittered and radicalized against him, Mr. McCormick has not. Instead, he used the time off after his defeat to craft a meaty intellectual defense of the part of Trumpism that is most consequential: the realignment of America’s economic posture toward the rest of the world.
This attempt to integrate the New Right — populist, brash, disruptive — with the proven foundations of the Old Right is the most interesting and important project in American conservatism today, and Mr. McCormick’s book shows he is suited to the task.

A former CEO of Bridgewater Associates and Treasury official in the Bush Administration, no one can doubt Dave McCormick has an ample grasp of the real economy. Populists may be initially skeptical of that training, but his hawkishness on China will compel them to read on — and find a thesis they can support.
This is where the other side of Mr. McCormick’s background comes in. As a West Point graduate and Army veteran, he sees the tensions in the more traditional conservative approach — free markets married to a robust national defense — and understands that we must subordinate an increasingly globalized capitalism to the demands of national security. Like Mr. Trump, Mr. McCormick sees a rising China not just as a geo-political rival, but as “the greatest external threat to American renewal.” He recalls the personal experiences that convinced him of China’s malevolent intentions toward the United States, which came as he served on the staff of the National Security Council and in the U.S. Treasury: “China’s leaders believe we are in decline and want to keep it that way.”
The free market makes no distinction between friend and foe, which is the source of much of its strength. But that’s no longer a compromise American can be willing to make.
As a former Chair of the Asia Subcommittee in the U.S. Senate’s Foreign Relations Committee, I saw more than enough to convince myself of the need to adjust our approach to trade, investment and entanglement with Chinese entities. Anyone who has approached the Chinese problem with sincere optimism comes away as a hard-nosed realist about the need for tough action, and what Mr. McCormick calls “strategic decoupling.”
In Superpower In Peril, written with James Cunningham, Mr. McCormick outlines a layered China Strategy essential for American survival. It’s appropriately confrontational but isn’t scattershot or emotional. The argument makes important distinctions, like understanding the importance of allowing American brands like Harley-Davidson to make motorcycles in China for delivery to Asian markets, while also maintaining factories and supply lines in Pennsylvania. At the same time, the U.S. can and should starve China’s semi-conductor industry and other strategic high-tech businesses of American capital.
Mr. McCormick’s experience managing an investment portfolio and wrestling with how to make nuanced security distinctions makes his hawkishness on China more authentic than the usual platitudes. He understands that decoupling our economy from China’s won’t be simple or easy, but is almost certainly necessary.

The American renewal that Mr. McCormick proposes is not merely economic: He also makes data-driven arguments for a cultural wake-up. He takes on Silicon Valley’s voracious, amoral profiteering at the expense of social norms and young people’s mental health. And he asks hard questions about the strategic risks of skilled labor prioritization in immigration policy, and outlines its upsides. This kind of debate does not fit easily into brash Trumpian campaign speeches, but it’s one America must have if we are to recalibrate our approach to the international scene, and to China in particular.
It has become common in the newly populist Republican Party to criticize bigness generally — corporate, governmental, academic — and Mr. McCormick takes his own stab it. He writes that the path to fixing our broken institutions is to break the monopoly “bureaucratic and elite capture” has over them — best represented by the so-called ESG (environmental, social and governance) and DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) initiatives rampant today in academia, corporate America, the military and federal agencies.
This critique of the highest echelons of corporate America and the military is notable because it comes from an author with experience in both. The problem isn’t just “big government” anymore: A true conservatism requires understanding that most elite institutions operate with, and attempt to inculcate in society, the same progressive values. Specifically, Mr. McCormick says the problem is a “drift from the notion of merit as the key principle driving decision” toward a search for left-wing ideological purity, exemplified by the phenomenon of “virtue signaling.”
One-time (and maybe future) U.S. Senate candidate Dave McCormick has made an unusual choice: Rather than releasing a lame campaign biography or experimenting with poll-tested messaging, he has articulated the intellectual foundations for a pragmatic and principled conservatism for our time. In doing so, he has maintained the best of the old Reaganite premises while applying them to a new political order, with new threats both internal and external. And through it all, he remains a happy warrior — but one who has traded his libertarian Milton Friedman textbooks for edgier tools, admitting that “my own party has been far too slow to realize that the old Republican orthodoxy wasn’t cutting it.”
Historically, the conservative GOP has by definition clung to old things and been slow to adapt, while the New Right screams that a progressive cultural cancer and the growing threat posed by China make inertia unacceptable. The Old Right has struggled with stale ideas, while the New Right has struggled to find a strategy longer than a tweet.
Dave McCormick offers a way forward that respects the old while giving substance to the new. Whether or not he ever runs for office again, my fellow Republicans would be wise to give him their ears.
Cory Gardner is a former United States senator and representative from Colorado.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.