It’s time we have a different debate over education in Pennsylvania. The conversation must be about more than simply how much money we spend.

Educational funding and academic attainment uncoupled long ago. A glance at statewide test scores and per-pupil spending shows little correlation between what taxpayers supply and what districts produce.

Pennsylvania is outspending even the highest performing education systems. For instance, Singapore is one of the top education systems in the world, spending about $11,000 per student. By comparison, Pennsylvania spends twice as much per student. And while the Commonwealth usually ranks fairly high compared with other U.S. states, the United States education system is far behind in math, science and reading scores, and does not even break into the top 10 when compared to other countries.

The question of effective education is not about spending more. It is about spending wisely.

Advertise with us

Catching up

That is, in part, what the state’s Commission of Education and Economic Competitiveness is confronting in exploring ways we can make public education relevant to a job market in which technology is accelerating, but the population of young people ready to fill the available jobs continues to stagnate. It is astonishing to think that manufacturing — among the best paying sectors in the job market — cannot find enough workers to fill the jobs.

How can this be? Part of the answer can be learned by visiting a modern factory floor, where much of the work is performed by sophisticated machines that demand an entirely different skill set than the factories of the past. This acceleration has been abrupt, fluid and disorienting for employers, jobseekers and policy makers alike as we all search for a way to prepare the population for an ever-shifting job landscape.

We must stop educating young people for an outdated economy by ending the implicit stigma attached to jobs that don’t require a college degree. We must recognize that the skills for today’s trades can be as demanding and rewarding as any liberal arts course; and we must produce a workforce ready to thrive in the new marketplace rather than scrape by.

The right questions

In a sharp editorial in November, the Post-Gazette defined the issue squarely by asking the right questions:

What new sectors built on new technologies could be tentpole industries for Pittsburgh decades and generations from now? And who will work in those industries? And how will they learn what they need to know to do so?

Advertise with us

The Commission is tasked with bringing together representatives from labor, education, business and government to ask those very questions and to formulate plausible answers. In many ways, we will be asking our educators to adopt new ways of thinking. As a work in progress, the Commission needs to hear not only from educators and lawmakers, but the Pennsylvanians who finance our school system and whose children are morally entitled to an opportunity for success.

But we can’t expect to get the right answers without asking the correct questions. This will demand the curiosity to think in new ways and the courage to cast aside some cherished illusions, chief among them equating a university degree with full membership in the economy. Ralph Waldo Emerson once declared, “The things we learn in schools and colleges are not an education but a means of an education.”

The liberal arts and social sciences are great means of rounding out an intellect and shaping character. But the big philosophy firms aren’t hiring this year.

Knowledge for success

We need to set aside the idea that every degree confers a working career. Indeed, over half of college graduates in the U.S. are underemployed (employed in jobs that don’t typically require a college degree). Likewise, we must abandon the shopworn notion that a job not based on university qualifications is not worthy of respect, even admiration.

Charles Zogby, a lifetime public servant who distinguished himself in every post from Secretary of Education to Budget Secretary, once spoke before the graduates at a trade school and reminded them: “Whenever a pipe bursts in the basement, my wife doesn’t say, ‘thank heavens you’re a lawyer.’”

Advertise with us

Many of those graduates are now out-earning people with advanced degrees and their lives are no less full. In fact, I would venture that several went on to round themselves out with a college degree because, to quote the founder of Faber College, “Knowledge is good.”

But knowledge of things that put students in control of their economic destinies is, arguably, the best kind. Our public schools — our entire educational system — should retool to adapt to that truth. We need a collective vision of what kind of education our young people must have. That vision must be the guiding light for our schools that send our future generations into a world for which they are prepared — a world in which they can succeed and prosper thanks to their skills.

Ryan Aument, a Republican state senator serving Lancaster, is majority whip in the Pennsylvania Senate. His previous article was “What to do when the universities won’t act against antisemitism.”