The morning after the election of Richard Nixon in 1968, Sen. Eugene J. McCarthy said: “This is a day for visiting the sick and burying the dead.” Richard Nixon appears civilized now. He knew his craft and had some sense of shame and limits.
On the morning of the 2024 election I made two lists, one of the reasons Kamala Harris would win and the other of the reasons Donald Trump would win.
The voters’ reasons
If she wins it will be because: She ran a good campaign; the Supreme Court of the United States changed the rules on legal abortion; she presented as a likable and intelligent person, and a joyful warrior; she was a dignified and professional politician, an antidote to chaotic nihilism; she was optimistic and upbeat about America.
If he wins it will be because: Roughly half the people in the country, and a little more than half in the swing states, don’t want any of that.
All of the reasons for Kamala are rational — what old-hand politicos like James Carville and Stuart Stevens call “the fundamentals.” The fundamentals did not prevail here. This election was not about the sort of politics that professionals at politics recognize. This election was the triumph of irrationality.
Donald Trump ran his most crass, ugly campaign yet, and did his best yet. In the final weeks of the campaign he was at his most belligerent and unhinged, and on election day he did better than even he and his campaign staff dared to hope.
Read More
It was not only the defeat of reason and of political professionalism, with compromise and moderation as the result, it was the defeat of decency. At least for now.
Mr. Carville said, before the election, that he refused to believe that Trump’s America is who we are. But in this moment it is who we are: Angry and we don’t quite know why. Full of grievance and we can’t be satisfied. And crass.
Mr. Trump channels and epitomizes it all. Not the America of Lincoln and King and Rosa Parks and Jonas Salk and Rachel Carson. But the America of road rage, and young men addicted to porn, and old men wearing ball caps in restaurants, and TV shows where spouses kill each other, and movies in which human heads are blown off and apart.
The scholar and senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan said that culture shapes politics. Our culture is unkind, gauche, and menacing. Again, Mr. Trump epitomizes.
Trumpist posturing
Moynihan also said that politics can sometimes nudge culture. Conventional politicians cannot grasp, or even fully recognize, Trumpism because Trumpism isn’t about change or building. It’s about acting out. Posture.
Just like Trumpism’s favorite whipping boy — the “left.” It’s all about posture. Instead of burning a flag, the Trumper defiles decency. Which raises the most distasteful irony of Trumpism — its claim to being Christian, patriotic, and Republican.
A Christian is appalled at cruelty and indifference. A true patriot loves the Constitution more than king or cult. True Republicans, and republicans, especially, care for what Burke called “the decent drapery of life.”
It is up to approximate followers of Jesus of Nazareth, patriots, humanists, sincere followers of the Old Testament or Allah, and all who put on the mantle of the citizen (as opposed to the entitled malcontent), to defend decency and reason. And to keep insisting that, no, this is not who we want to be.
We need to make this insistence person-to-person and at the grass roots. Make the case. Build. We still have a democratic republic. We live to fight another day.
The legal immigrants who built this nation, and are now being demonized, are required, as an act of citizenship, to learn the fundamentals of American democracy. Some of these include respect for the Bill of Rights, the rule of law, and the peaceful transfer of power. I don’t think most Americans today have much idea about these things.
And we have very little idea about what anti-democracy is. For there is a yahoo fascism abroad in the land. It is characterized, in part, by a kind of moral slovenliness – a resistance to seriousness about things that matter, like war and peace, justice, and history. A resistance to knowledge and thinking.
Moynihan also used to say that if anything sinks America, it will be our intolerance of complexity. This is what the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr called “primitivism.”
Primitivism beat decency and reason in this election. And maybe it will hold the upper hand for a time. But I do not think it will have the final say. For indiscriminate rage is the road to moral poverty, material poverty and great unhappiness.
Primitivism won’t last
Primitivism is reckless. It would be reckless to hire Donald Trump to drive a bus.
Primitivism devours itself. It keeps reducing, keeps simplifying down, until there is nothing left but a primal scream.
And human beings need a reason to get out of bed in the morning. They need decency and reason. The possibility of friendship and connection. Hope.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “I won't forsake my Trumper friends.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.