It’s been an exhausting autumn, and we’re only at the beginning. Weekends are filled with birthday parties, pumpkin patches, and festivals. For those of us that are Jewish, the High Holy Days are among us. For all of us, it’s pumpkin spice, apple-picking and costume-planning time.
The folks on my street have put out their Halloween decorations, and at last Saturday’s most excellent block party, the kids ran around with face paint, sparklers and too much cheesecake in their bellies. It’s the best time of year in our city — and one I relish.
It’s a time for kindness in the age of meanness, a time of apples and honey for the upcoming new year (shana tova!), and a time to sit on camping chairs with your neighbors, basking in the sweetness of the season.
Everybody talks, everybody talks
According to the experts, that might only be true on my block these days. This election season has brought out the worst in all of us, rhetorically speaking.
“Discourse is meaner today than it’s ever been,” a linguistics expert affiliated with the University of Maryland told me in a telephone interview.
“If you analyze language patterns, people are increasingly accusing one another of hypocrisy, willful ignorance and incivility on public forums on historic levels — think Vietnam, think the Civil War,” he said.
“The language we use to address one another reveals how conciliatory, how open to agreement, and how willing to listen we are,” he continued. “Right now, we’re more likely to think poorly of one another instead of granting one another the benefit of the doubt.”
I see this often enough — it’s why so many dinner tables institute a “no politics, no religion” policy rather than attempt a reasonable discussion.
“The language we choose determines a conversation’s success (where two people fully grasp each other’s meaning),” he added. “Hyperbole makes compromise difficult.”
I could hear the chit-chat
There’s an argument on Facebook happening right now.
My friend Alex believes that ABC was unfair to Donald Trump in the last debate, fact-checking him more than his opponent. My friend Abel believes that Donald Trump lied more than his opponent, and ABC did their job, treating both debaters proportionally and fairly.
Their online argument has gone on for weeks and has become a series of nasty attacks on each other’s credibility. They are both intelligent, and kind, people outside the bubble of social media. But in their back-and-forth, both attempt to maintain moral, ethical and rhetorical superiority. Neither is listening to the valid points the other makes. Neither is coming off well.
More importantly, neither is doing a good job of convincing the other of anything. Every time Abel points out that Trump spreads objectively bad information, Alex responds with statistics about the border. Abel counters by insulting Alex’s education. Alex counters by calling Abel a Communist, even though no one has been discussing seizing the means of production.
I’ve been thinking about my language choices a lot these days, deliberating between my prescriptivist (words have established meanings!) tendencies and the descriptivist (language evolves!) world we live in. I tend to agree with Abel, but I know that Alex believes he is coming from a good place too. It’s hard to find words that won’t push him further away.
The distance has never been wider between what the Alexes and Abels of the world mean to say, what they are actually saying and what the other person hears.
It started with a whisper
It was an October day back in 2008 when Republican John McCain defended Democrat Barack Obama after a woman questioned the latter’s eligibility for office.
“No ma’am, he’s a decent family man, citizen, that I just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues, and that’s what this campaign is all about,” McCain said.
He gave a beautiful answer, one that focused on kindness, and doing the right thing. McCain chose not to resort to baseless attacks to campaign against this opponent.
Our political discourse has lost this — I cannot imagine either candidate speaking this well of the other. To channel the words of the great Joseph N. Welch, have we lost our sense of decency, at long last?
As I cut up apples for the apple-and-honey tart I’m planning to bake, I notice how the goodness of the fruit belies its sweetness. It is possible to be healthy and kind, sweet and sour, all at the same time.
It is possible to critique someone without calling them deranged or mentally unfit, to disagree on fundamental issues without resorting to the worst language available. But … enough of that.
It’s autumn, and I’m planning on taking the kids on a hayride next weekend. There’s too much joy in the air, too much kindness on my street; it cannot be ignored.
Correction: a previous version of this article misstated the network that aired the debate.
This Friday, Oct. 4, at 7PM at White Whale Bookstore, Ramírez will be reading with other local poets to help get out the vote. More info at whitewhalebookstore.com
Previous article: It’s never been a woman’s world







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.