With over 10,000 peace­keep­ers from 50 coun­tries and a bud­get of half a bil­lion dol­lars a year — 28% of which is pro­vided by Amer­i­can tax­pay­ers — the United Na­tions In­terim Force in Leb­a­non has gen­er­ally been a fail­ure.

When­ever hos­til­i­ties break­out be­tween Is­rael and ter­ror­ist or­ga­ni­za­tions op­er­at­ing in south­ern Leb­a­non, the peace­keep­ers are ig­nored, pushed aside or even at­tacked by Is­rael. The “in­terim” in UNIFIL’s name is a bit of a mis­no­mer, as it was es­tab­lished over 46 years ago and there is no end in sight to its mis­sion.

No peace to keep

Peace­keep­ers can­not be suc­cess­ful when there is no peace to keep. But whose fault is it that this sim­ple fact never seems to be learned? It’s not the UN, it’s the U.S. (and other na­tions.)

In more peace­ful times, UNIFIL sol­diers make hun­dreds of pa­trols each month of the area that is sup­posed to be off lim­its to any armed groups be­sides the Leb­a­nese army, but these ef­forts are worth­less.

Advertise with us

The peace­keep­ers are not au­tho­rized to search build­ings, or even ve­hi­cles, to lo­cate the weap­ons that the Ira­nian-backed Hez­bol­lah mi­li­tia has been busy stock­pil­ing for years. When the war be­tween Ha­mas ter­ror­ists in Gaza and Is­rael started a year ago, Hez­bol­lah joined in launch­ing hun­dreds of rock­ets and drones at Is­rael from their po­si­tions in south­ern Leb­a­non. And it con­tin­ues to do so.

While pro­tec­tion of ci­vil­ians is part of UNIFIL’s man­date, the peace­keep­ers are re­luc­tant to use force even to pro­tect them­selves, if it means start­ing a fight with the lo­cal pop­u­la­tion that could eas­ily es­ca­late. When con­fronted by armed ci­vil­ians while on pa­trol, they have had to call on the Leb­a­nese Armed Forces to have them­selves ex­tri­cated.

It is also ob­vi­ous that a UN mil­i­tary force made up of lightly armed sol­diers from 50 dif­fer­ent coun­tries who have no ar­til­lery, air sup­port or tanks is not a ca­pa­ble com­bat force. The idea UNIFIL could ever com­pel ei­ther the Is­rae­lis or Hez­bol­lah fight­ers to stop fight­ing can there­fore be safely dis­carded. This dem­on­strates an­other tru­ism: peace­keep­ers are not ef­fec­tive war fight­ers and never will be.

Inef­fec­tive UNIFIL

So, who is re­spon­si­ble for the in­ef­fec­tive­ness of UNIFIL? Not the peace­keep­ers who have been handed a mis­sion im­pos­sible. Peace­keep­ing op­er­a­tions are launched and given their or­ders and rules of en­gage­ment by the UN Se­cu­rity Coun­cil.

The Coun­cil is dom­i­nated by the five coun­tries who are its per­ma­nent mem­bers, the main win­ners of World War II and the first five na­tions to ac­quire nu­clear weap­ons. Each of them has the power to veto any­thing the Coun­cil tries to do.

Advertise with us

In some con­flict sit­u­a­tions, the Coun­cil feels com­pelled to act and that is mainly when the in­ter­ests of one of more of the Per­ma­nent Five are in­volved. That is es­pe­cially true of the long-run­ning hos­til­i­ties be­tween Is­rael and its neigh­bors. There are four peace­keep­ing op­er­a­tions in and around Is­rael and none of them is ac­com­plish­ing much of any­thing.

Is­rael and Leb­a­non are fighting be­cause the lat­ter has been a failed state for years. The med­dling of Syria, and now Iran, added to the lack of any will­ing­ness of the Leb­a­nese to put aside their re­li­gious dif­fer­ences for the sake of na­tional unity, has re­sulted in a gov­ern­ment that has been un­able to con­trol its own ter­ri­tory and pre­vent at­tacks on Is­rael.

To give the ap­pear­ance of do­ing some­thing to ad­dress this long-run­ning con­flict, the U.S. and the rest of the Se­cu­rity Coun­cil or­dered the UN to put to­gether a peace­keep­ing force and march off to Leb­a­non where the war­ring par­ties are not all that in­ter­ested in peace. In those times when there has been no ac­tual fight­ing, the peace­keep­ers en­gage in busy work like un­pro­duc­tive pa­trol­ling to try to con­vey the il­lu­sion that they are con­trib­ut­ing to peace.

But since the in­ter­na­tional com­mu­nity is un­able or un­will­ing to deal with the un­der­ly­ing causes of the con­flict, that peace is imag­i­nary.

Les­sons ig­nored

These les­sons con­tinue to be will­fully ig­nored and UNIFIL will no doubt re­main in op­er­a­tion de­spite Is­raeli de­mands that it be with­drawn. Is­rael does not want UNIFIL in the way as it re­tal­i­ates against Hez­bol­lah, but while it may be forced back for a time, it will not be elim­i­nated. So, the peace­keep­ers will re­main, and any peace will be tem­po­rary.

Advertise with us

There is one other dis­tinc­tion that UNIFIL holds be­sides its in­ef­fec­tive­ness. It has the record among all UN peace­keep­ing op­er­a­tions for the high­est num­ber of fa­tal­i­ties at 337. A toll that will no doubt go up as the war goes on.

Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, is professor of international affairs at the Pennsylvania State University and the author of "Why Peacekeeping Fails.” His previous article was “The attempt to Benghazi Joe Biden is wrong.”