With over 10,000 peacekeepers from 50 countries and a budget of half a billion dollars a year — 28% of which is provided by American taxpayers — the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon has generally been a failure.
Whenever hostilities breakout between Israel and terrorist organizations operating in southern Lebanon, the peacekeepers are ignored, pushed aside or even attacked by Israel. The “interim” in UNIFIL’s name is a bit of a misnomer, as it was established over 46 years ago and there is no end in sight to its mission.
No peace to keep
Peacekeepers cannot be successful when there is no peace to keep. But whose fault is it that this simple fact never seems to be learned? It’s not the UN, it’s the U.S. (and other nations.)
In more peaceful times, UNIFIL soldiers make hundreds of patrols each month of the area that is supposed to be off limits to any armed groups besides the Lebanese army, but these efforts are worthless.
The peacekeepers are not authorized to search buildings, or even vehicles, to locate the weapons that the Iranian-backed Hezbollah militia has been busy stockpiling for years. When the war between Hamas terrorists in Gaza and Israel started a year ago, Hezbollah joined in launching hundreds of rockets and drones at Israel from their positions in southern Lebanon. And it continues to do so.
While protection of civilians is part of UNIFIL’s mandate, the peacekeepers are reluctant to use force even to protect themselves, if it means starting a fight with the local population that could easily escalate. When confronted by armed civilians while on patrol, they have had to call on the Lebanese Armed Forces to have themselves extricated.
Read More
It is also obvious that a UN military force made up of lightly armed soldiers from 50 different countries who have no artillery, air support or tanks is not a capable combat force. The idea UNIFIL could ever compel either the Israelis or Hezbollah fighters to stop fighting can therefore be safely discarded. This demonstrates another truism: peacekeepers are not effective war fighters and never will be.
Ineffective UNIFIL
So, who is responsible for the ineffectiveness of UNIFIL? Not the peacekeepers who have been handed a mission impossible. Peacekeeping operations are launched and given their orders and rules of engagement by the UN Security Council.
The Council is dominated by the five countries who are its permanent members, the main winners of World War II and the first five nations to acquire nuclear weapons. Each of them has the power to veto anything the Council tries to do.
In some conflict situations, the Council feels compelled to act and that is mainly when the interests of one of more of the Permanent Five are involved. That is especially true of the long-running hostilities between Israel and its neighbors. There are four peacekeeping operations in and around Israel and none of them is accomplishing much of anything.
Israel and Lebanon are fighting because the latter has been a failed state for years. The meddling of Syria, and now Iran, added to the lack of any willingness of the Lebanese to put aside their religious differences for the sake of national unity, has resulted in a government that has been unable to control its own territory and prevent attacks on Israel.
To give the appearance of doing something to address this long-running conflict, the U.S. and the rest of the Security Council ordered the UN to put together a peacekeeping force and march off to Lebanon where the warring parties are not all that interested in peace. In those times when there has been no actual fighting, the peacekeepers engage in busy work like unproductive patrolling to try to convey the illusion that they are contributing to peace.
But since the international community is unable or unwilling to deal with the underlying causes of the conflict, that peace is imaginary.
Lessons ignored
These lessons continue to be willfully ignored and UNIFIL will no doubt remain in operation despite Israeli demands that it be withdrawn. Israel does not want UNIFIL in the way as it retaliates against Hezbollah, but while it may be forced back for a time, it will not be eliminated. So, the peacekeepers will remain, and any peace will be temporary.
There is one other distinction that UNIFIL holds besides its ineffectiveness. It has the record among all UN peacekeeping operations for the highest number of fatalities at 337. A toll that will no doubt go up as the war goes on.
Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, is professor of international affairs at the Pennsylvania State University and the author of "Why Peacekeeping Fails.” His previous article was “The attempt to Benghazi Joe Biden is wrong.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.